A member asked:

If my bmi says im overweight but im fit and have a lot of muscle. am i unhealthy, do i need to lose weight?

2 doctors weighed in across 2 answers
Dr. John Chiu answered

No: BMI is just a rough measure. It is more important to be fit. Some experts suggest that the waist line size is a better indicator for assessment. Since muscle is heavier than fat, it is not surprising that you are considered overweight when measured by BMI.

Answered 7/31/2018

293 views

Thank

Research tool: The BMI is based on several generalizations. These include that a person of a given age would have an "average" amount of muscle & bone & organs and all the rest would be fat. It is a better tool for looking at large populations than individuals. If your body fat content is down in the 10-12% range as many athletes are at your age the BMI is not going to be an accurate measure of your fitness.

Answered 7/31/2018

293 views

Thank

Related Questions

Sponsored Content
HealthTap Medical Group does not endorse products or services. Sponsored content revenues support our mission to make health information free and accessible to all.Learn more