Question 1

what's more effective citrucel or metamucil?

Accepted Answer

Both equally: Metamucil contains psyllium which could make someone more gassy.

Question 2

what is the difference between citrucel & metamucil?

Accepted Answer

Fiber: Citrucel is methylcellullose. Metamucil is psyllium. These are 2 types of fiber. Is one better than the other? I think citrucel tastes slightly better than metamucil, but that is a personal opinion.

Question 3

what are some of the precautions when taking metamucil and citrucel?

Accepted Answer

Drink Plenty of H2O: Fiber acts like a sponge in the intestinal tract, providing "bulk" to help treat constipation. It is not a medicine--nothing is absorbed into your system. Like any sponge, it requires liquid to become effective--otherwise, it can actually cause constipation. Make an active effort to drink 64 ounces of water a day.

Question 4

which is the most effective product of the following: benefiber, metamucil, or citrucel?

Accepted Answer

All effective: Theses are just supplements.  All are effective but i caution that while taking benefiber you have to make sure you drink lots of water with it.  But these just supplement your diet.  Most people need 25-30 grams a day and it is impossible to get this just from these products.  You still have to change your diet and get it there.  Consult with your physician for more info.

Question 5

which is more effective for ibs-d: metamucil or citrucel?

Accepted Answer

About the same: Both are soluble fibers and will soak up liquids. Metamucil  is ferment able so make cause more bloating than citrucel. Start slowly ; work your way up.

Question 6

happy july 4th doctors. which do you recommend/prefer among konsyl, metamucil, benefiber, citrucel? is it safe to take these with miralax?

Accepted Answer

: Any of these can help regulate bowel function if you have irritable bowel syndrome, constipation, etc. Different persons have different responses to each of them. Discuss options with your doctor; or try them all at different times. Good luck.

Question 7

what causes intestinal bloating? looks like i am pregnant. could lose 10lbs, but not really overweight. more fiber? metamucil or citrucel?

Accepted Answer

Healthy diet: Try eating a healthy diet before resorting to medication. Plenty of fruits and vegetables, lean meat, and plenty of water. Stay away from all sweets, processed food, soft drinks, and fast food. After several days your digestive system should straighten out. If not check with your physician.

Question 8

very good afternoon doctors. for occasional constipation, is it better to take miralax or a fiber supplement like metamucil or benefiber or citrucel or both miralax and a fiber supplement together? which fiber supplement do you recommend?

Accepted Answer

: For occasional constipation, I would try the fiber supplement first. This may be just enough to regulate the bowel movements. The fiber supplements are all about the same so whichever is easier for you to get and is affordable would be suitable. If this doesn’t solve the problem, you may want to see your doctor prior to taking any medicine for it to review possible dietary interventions. Good luck

Question 9

can metamucil give you hemorroids?

Accepted Answer

Would be expected: to lower strain and lower risk of them

Question 10

will metamucil deplete your sodium levels?

Accepted Answer

Why would U so think: Fiber, of both water soluble and water insoluble variety, provides health benefits.  Fiber accelerates how quickly food transits through the gut.  Fiber adds bulk to stool and improves bowel regularity.  Fiber can be used as an adjunct to weight loss by filling you up without excess calories, and in so doing restricting fat intake.  But too much fiber can make you gassy and increase stool volume.

Get Virtual Care

For Businesses

About Us

HealthTap Online Primary Care Doctors Accepting New Patients

Doctor answers about:

Which is better metamucil or citrucel

A member asked:

What's more effective citrucel or metamucil?

A member asked:

What is the difference between citrucel & metamucil?

A member asked:

What are some of the precautions when taking metamucil and citrucel?

A member asked:

Which is the most effective product of the following: benefiber, metamucil, or citrucel?

A member asked:

Which is more effective for ibs-d: metamucil or citrucel?

A member asked:

Happy july 4th doctors. which do you recommend/prefer among konsyl, metamucil, benefiber, citrucel? is it safe to take these with miralax?

A member asked:

What causes intestinal bloating? looks like i am pregnant. could lose 10lbs, but not really overweight. more fiber? metamucil or citrucel?

A member asked:

Very good afternoon doctors. for occasional constipation, is it better to take miralax or a fiber supplement like metamucil or benefiber or citrucel or both miralax and a fiber supplement together? which fiber supplement do you recommend?

A member asked:

Can metamucil give you hemorroids?

A member asked:

Will metamucil deplete your sodium levels?

Sponsored Content

HealthTap Online Primary Care Doctors Accepting New Patients

Telemedicine

Primary Care

Manage Your Conditions

Women's Health

Children's Health

Men's Health

Senior Health

Wellness, Prevention & Lifestyle

Sexual Health

Mental & Behavioral Health

Travel Medicine

Urgent Care

Didn't find what you're looking for?

More of what we treat

Allergies

Antibiotics

Asthma

High Blood Pressure

Prescriptions

Type 2 Diabetes

For Businesses

Company

Health Content

Join Us

Download HealthTap

Questions?