A member asked:

Is a cool mist or a warm mist humidifier recommended for children and why?

16 doctors weighed in across 7 answers

No: It just is not necessary, although it is useful in croup.

Answered 1/23/2012

6.1k views

Thank

Depends on local: In the north, where humidity is often handles passively by a furnace add on, these have little use. In the south, where dry heat is the rule, children and adults may become symptomatic during long cool spells. Headaches, sore throats, nose bleeds & dry coughs are often related to heater related humidities in the 10-20% range.Babies are very sensitive to these issues.I recomend them.

Answered 6/1/2012

6.1k views

Thank

Cool Mist: If you choose to use a humidifier, cool mist is preferred. The heating of the water in a warm mist humidifier promotes mold and bacterial growth that can have adverse effects.

Answered 7/20/2012

6.1k views

Thank

Little difference: One the water vapor is aerosilized it quickly reaches room temperature. Cool mist is safer with toddlers since there is no chance for burns if there is contact with the vaporizer.

Answered 7/8/2015

6.1k views

Thank
Dr. Jay Park answered

Extra Moisture: Humidifiers or vaporizers have often been misused. Both of them provides extra moisture only to upper airway. Benefit has been noticed in infants or children with congested nose from simple cold or with croup. Cool mist is preferrable to warm one.

Answered 3/14/2019

6.1k views

Thank

Cool mist is safer: In general (with a few exceptions) it is more about raising the moisture level in the room. This is especially useful in winter months when the air is quite dry (at least in cold climates) and little noses and throats tend to be dry and irritated from all the colds going around. The real advantage to cool mist is that curious toddlers won't burn themselves when they grab the humidifier.

Answered 9/28/2016

6.1k views

Thank

May Not Matter: There is an old study that demonstrated cool air/moisture penetrates deeper into the respiratory tree. But not by much. There may be very little practical difference.

Answered 1/8/2015

6k views

Thank

Related Questions