What's schizophrenia: Dissoiciative disorder is losing a sense of self. In its extreme (which is way overdiagnosed) is multiple personality. Schizophrenia is disorganized thinking and hallucinations, often noticed more by others that the person who has it. They are very different and require a psychiatrist to help you determine. Schizophrenia definitely needs medication. Dissociative disorders usually don't.
Answered 5/1/2016
5.2k views
Yes: Schizophrenia does not involve amnesia. The voices tend to be either external or internal but they cannot enter into conversations with you if they are schizophrenic in nature, whereas if they are dissociative in nature they can carry out long conversations with you and you will indeed hear them carrying on conversations with each other in the background. Remember that it is possible to have both. I have treated people with up to three different types of psychoses at the same time, bipolar psychoses, dissociative psychoses, and drug-induced psychoses from jimson weed. People with dissociative disorder tend to get a lot of hang up phone calls at home. I will not elaborate on that here. People with dissociative disorders make purchases that they don't remember having made and carry on conversations with other people that they later do not recall. They have friends who call them bya different name and they are confused by this. I've even known one person to take two classes in college that were scheduled at the same time. She got a's in both classes. Family members of people with dissociative disorders will often find them curled up with a blanket or a teddy bear. They will often hide in closets or on the floor behind couches. They can be seen sucking their thumbs or talking in a little girls or little boys voice. The voices in schizophrenia talk at you but not with you. They often leave disparaging remarks. Also, the person with a dissociative disorder is much more likely to have underlying post traumatic stress disorder.
Answered 8/20/2013
4.9k views
4 doctors weighed in across 2 answers
A doctor has provided 1 answer
A doctor has provided 1 answer
90,000 U.S. doctors in 147 specialties are here to answer your questions or offer you advice, prescriptions, and more.
Ask your question