Question 1

in an alif, what factors go into your decision to use allograft vs autograft? which would you recommend for a patient with autoimmune issues?

Accepted Answer

Multiple factors: Using an allograft when it is possible prevents the need to harvest a bone graft. However in patients who are expected to have problems with healing and incorporation of a bone graft an autograft is preferable.

Question 2

having a difficult time making a decision between autograft and allograft acl replacement.  i am 38 years old but very active.  enjoy sports.

Accepted Answer

Equal results &gt; 35: Most meta analyses of outcome studies confirm clinical results are similar for ACL reconstructions in patients over 35. The most important factor for success is still location of graft placement, so surgeon skill and expertise are important

Question 3

for an acl ligament knee reconstruction if your hypermobile or have eds is it best to have an allograft rather than autograft to reduce failure risk?

Accepted Answer

Probably allograft : Good question  there is probably no statistically significant difference allograft reconstruction do well in many settings and eliminate donor site morbidity both grafts have a similar outcome

Question 4

i tore my acl. which autograft is better?

Accepted Answer

Either: Both hamstring and patella bone tendon bone autografts have excellent outcomes. Obviously each have their benefits and drawbacks.

If you cannot choose who your surgeon is, it may come down to what your surgeon is more comfortable or better at.

If you have the luxury of choosing your own surgeon, then you should press him/her on individualizing which is better for you.

Question 5

what are the current trends in acdf? is zero p one of the newest technology? what is its limitation? how good compared to autograft? what other inst?

Accepted Answer

Multiple: There are many new devices and materials for acdf. Zero-p or chesapeake are standalone devices.  Some of the new spacers are made of titanium or bioceramic.  Autograft remains the gold standard but has its own set of problems - persistent pain, second surgery site, etc.  Limitations on some of the newer devices are lesser likelihood of successful fusion.

Question 6

what is the definition or description of: autograft?

Accepted Answer

To yourself: Tissue taken from one part of the body and grafted onto another, for example, a skin graft from a healthy part placed over a portion of injured skin.

Question 7

i had an acl surgery (type  autograft)  23 days ago! swelling decreased a lot  after 17 days, but past 5 days and so, swelling has increased !?

Accepted Answer

Acl: Check with your doctor. May have to have the knee drained. May be blood, inflammation, or infection.

Question 8

acl reconstructed with hs autograft 6 months ago. last week it swelled up, i didnt feel any pain. is it acl failure or a meniscus tear ?

Accepted Answer

Hard to say: Swelling in absence of pain or traumatic event could be any number of things but definitely less concerning than these same findings in assoc w/ pain or twisting re-injury to knee.  If it persists for 10 days or more probably warrants re-evaluation by operating surgeon and if exam findings concerning probably repeat MRI to further evaluate.

Question 9

i'm having surgery for maltracking (lateral release medial pattellfemeroral reconstruction and autograft on hamstring) what should i expect?

Accepted Answer

A long recovery: While the initial recovery from the surgery will be measured in weeks, or a few months the full benefits of the surgery will take 6-12 months and include rehabilitation of the knee, especially quadriceps strengthening.  The good news is that with the correct diagnosis and in the correct hands patients having the operation you are having are very happy with the results.

Question 10

age22. 2months over with my acl surgery hamstring autograft. i have my exams for continous 15days.is it okay if i skip my leg exercises till dat time?

Accepted Answer

You should not: You should not discontinue your exercises.After acl reconstruction surgery they are specials protocols that need to be follow in order to get maximun beneficts fron the surgery, .

Get Virtual Care

For Businesses

About Us

HealthTap Online Primary Care Doctors Accepting New Patients

Doctor answers about:

Allograft vs autograft

A member asked:

In an alif, what factors go into your decision to use allograft vs autograft? which would you recommend for a patient with autoimmune issues?

A member asked:

Having a difficult time making a decision between autograft and allograft acl replacement. i am 38 years old but very active. enjoy sports.

A member asked:

For an acl ligament knee reconstruction if your hypermobile or have eds is it best to have an allograft rather than autograft to reduce failure risk?

A member asked:

I tore my acl. which autograft is better?

A member asked:

What are the current trends in acdf? is zero p one of the newest technology? what is its limitation? how good compared to autograft? what other inst?

A member asked:

What is the definition or description of: autograft?

A member asked:

I had an acl surgery (type autograft) 23 days ago! swelling decreased a lot after 17 days, but past 5 days and so, swelling has increased !?

A member asked:

Acl reconstructed with hs autograft 6 months ago. last week it swelled up, i didnt feel any pain. is it acl failure or a meniscus tear ?

A member asked:

I'm having surgery for maltracking (lateral release medial pattellfemeroral reconstruction and autograft on hamstring) what should i expect?

A member asked:

Age22. 2months over with my acl surgery hamstring autograft. i have my exams for continous 15days.is it okay if i skip my leg exercises till dat time?

HealthTap Online Primary Care Doctors Accepting New Patients

Telemedicine

Primary Care

Manage Your Conditions

Women's Health

Children's Health

Men's Health

Senior Health

Wellness, Prevention & Lifestyle

Sexual Health

Mental & Behavioral Health

Travel Medicine

Urgent Care

Didn't find what you're looking for?

More of what we treat

Allergies

Antibiotics

Asthma

High Blood Pressure

Prescriptions

Type 2 Diabetes

For Businesses

Company

Health Content

Join Us

Download HealthTap

Questions?