New shoes make my small toe hurt, what can i do?

Roomier toe box: You can use a shoe stretcher to stretch the area of the small toe in your new shoes. Or if the toe box or shoe tip of the new shoes is too narrow (too pointed) or too tight, you may want to exchange the shoes with ones that have a less narrow toebox. New shoes that make your toe(s) hurt is a sign they don't fit right, so you want shoes with a toebox that allows your toes to wiggle.