Herbst vs extraction i have two very different opinions from orthodontists. one suggests extraction of 5 and 13. the other suggests no extraction and herbst. help!

3rd opinion: Suggest you seek a 3rd opinion. Herbst appliances used primarily for growing children and tweens. Extractions indicated more often for non-growing adults. Without benefit of examination/diagnostic records, cannot give you a treatment opinion. Seeks 3rd opinion.

Herbst: I have always preferred the result that can be achieved by keeping all the bicuspids. As your daughter is just 12, the extra time and cost for the Herbst treatment - typically 14 - 18 months is completely justified by the more pleasing result. Having said that, a third consultation might set your mind at ease so consider seeking yet another opinion.