A member asked:

Is packing carnation instant breakfast mix good enough for emergency disaster food? could i eat it every day?

22 doctors weighed in across 11 answers

More varied & water: You could eat it every day. The general recommendation is to have food for at least three days and water. You may be better served by having cereal, nuts, dry fruit, granola bars etc and bottled water.

Answered 4/8/2016

1.7k views

Thank

Yes: I have no reason to doubt whether carnation instant breakfast mix is unsuited as emergency disaster food. If nothing else are available , carnation instant breakfast mix should be able to keep you alive for several days and more. In a long run, however, certain cautions are needed, such as excessive sugar content for daibetic patients, etc.

Answered 11/2/2017

1.7k views

Thank
Dr. Jerry Brown answered

Specializes in Prosthodontics

Breakfast On The Go!: Good day; You probably could survive on a daily dose of Carnation Instant Breakfast; however, a banana or an apple with a cereal bar could work as well. Try varying your breakfast choices - breakfast gives you morning fuel power!!

Answered 4/8/2016

1.7k views

Thank
Dr. Gabriel Malouf answered

Specializes in Dentistry

You could do better.: You can stay alive on it for a short while. However, with the same amount of time and expense, you could do better. Plan a variety, eat healthier and live happier for longer.

Answered 9/11/2016

989 views

Thank
Dr. Christine Hom answered

Specializes in Pediatrics

Mixes with milk: Carnation Instant Breakfast, at least in my area, is meant to be mixed with milk. That wouldn't be very good in an emergency. Think clean water and refrigeration.

Answered 10/9/2016

937 views

Thank
Dr. Mary Clifton answered

Specializes in Internal Medicine

Eat rice and beans: All over the world, people eat rice and beans as a complete protein and excellent source of antioxidants and vitamins. Choose canned or dried beans and rice for great shelf life and excellent nutrition in disaster and every day.

Answered 11/27/2017

937 views

Thank
Dr. James Okamoto answered

Specializes in Family Medicine

A couple problems: Carnation Instant Breakfast is not meant to be a sole source of nutrition. From their website: "not designed to provide sole-source nutrition. Although each 8 fl ozis rich in protein and provides 21 vitamins and minerals, it does not provide sufficient levels of essential nutrients including chromium, molybdenum and selenium".It would serve as a meal, but where will you get the milk in a disaster?

Answered 11/27/2017

937 views

Thank
Dr. John Chiu answered

Yes: The body can handle it quite well for at least a month or two. In case there is no other option, any food energy source is acceptable during a disaster.

Answered 10/10/2016

935 views

Thank

Not enough: People need a mixture of nutrients and hydration. A typical day should include 24 to 48 oz of water, 20 grams of protein, 15 grams of fat, and 30 grams of carbs. We also need water, potassium, sodium. A minimum of 15 calories of food per pound of body weight--you should plan for enough for three days at least. And if you are going to be expending energy, like work, double the amount.

Answered 10/11/2016

934 views

Thank

Yes: I see no reason why you couldn't, but you may have to boil your water before using it if public health agency issues a warning about your drinking water being contaminated.

Answered 10/11/2016

934 views

Thank
Dr. Clarence Grim answered

Specializes in Endocrinology

Instantfood disaster: 32 M US asks: Is packing Carnation Instant Breakfast mix good enough for emergency disaster food? Could I eat it every day? ANS: yes but do you need clear water to mix and need to heat it up? if so and no elect or water big problem. Recommend purchasing some survival packages that will do you good for 5 days. And store water. Be prepared.

Answered 10/23/2017

934 views

Thank

Related Questions