A member asked:

Is proton therapy the best radiation solution for prostate cancer.?

3 doctors weighed in across 3 answers
Dr. William A Biermann answered

Specializes in Medical Oncology

Not clear at all: This is a relatively new approach to target the prostate gland in a different way. A new kind of mouse trap. There is currently insufficient data to say that it is better than other treatments for prostate ca. It is only done at a few centers because of the equipment expense. The future of the field is a genomic test in development that hopefully will detemine if any treatment is appropriate.

Answered 9/28/2016

5.7k views

Thank
Dr. Addagada Rao answered

Specializes in General Surgery

Slightly better edge: Proton radiation has a better advantage than traditional radiation, it causes less complications, proton mass with positive charge will not pass beyond the tumor, precise high is delivered at the tumor. Proton generators are very expensive, available centers are limited.

Answered 8/8/2012

5.7k views

Thank
Dr. Jeffrey Buchsbaum answered

Specializes in Radiation Oncology

Complex question: This is highly debated at present. If every option cost the same, it might be the best external beam option. Data questioning it recently are retrospective, based on 65yo+ data sets, and cost biased. That being said, one can get great surgery (and bad), great imrt (and bad) and great observation (and bad). The best treatment is unique to a person's situation (and their teams experience).

Answered 9/28/2016

4.9k views

Thank

Related Questions