Is radiation treatment always necessary? as in, after a lumpectomy for stage 1 breast cancer, will a doctor always assign that you get radiation treatment, or does it depend on the patient?

Question

I had a lumpectomy for breast cancer and also had chemotherapy as it was grade 3. Now, the doctors want me to have radiations and take tamoxifen, but i'm fed up with the treatment. What should I do?

Answer 1

Yes: A lumpectomy alone is insufficient rx for invasive breast cancer; radiation therapy is always necessary to lower the risk of local recurrence, except under unusual circumstances (ie, elderly pt w/small tumor& very poor health). Dcis (stage 0) may sometimes be treated by lumpectomy alone, depending on unique patient & tumor characteristics.

Created for people with ongoing healthcare needs but benefits everyone.

Learn how we can help

Answer 2

Breast cancer: Lumpectomy for breast cancer is followed by radiation treatment for local control.

Created for people with ongoing healthcare needs but benefits everyone.

Learn how we can help

Answer 3

Usually yes: Most of the time rdiation treatment is needed to provide comparable longterm survival benefit in comparison to mastectomy. In women over 70 years old and if the cancer is esterogen receptor positive, endocrine therapy may be substitued with satisfactory results. You need to talk with your surgeon, medical oncologist as well a radiation oncologist to see what your particular cirmumstance will be.

Created for people with ongoing healthcare needs but benefits everyone.

Learn how we can help

Answer 4

Most likely: Trials have shown that lumpectomy folllowed by radiation for early stage breast cancer is equivalent to mastectomy. All women benefit from an improvement in local control, that is preventing the cancer from coming back in the breast. Women younger than 70-75 also are likely to live long enough to see a survival advantage after radiation therapy as well.

Created for people with ongoing healthcare needs but benefits everyone.

Learn how we can help

Is radiation treatment always necessary? as in, after a lumpectomy for stage 1 breast cancer, will a doctor always assign that you get radiation treatment, or does it depend on the patient?

Ask U.S. doctors your own question and get educational, text answers — it's anonymous and free!

Ask U.S. doctors your own question and get educational, text answers — it's anonymous and free!

HealthTap doctors are based in the U.S., board certified, and available by text or video.

Ask your Breast Surgery question free

Talk to a primary care doctor now for a personalized answer to your Breast Surgery question

Trusted by millions since 2010

Similar questions

After a lumpectomy for stage 1 breast cancer, will a doctor always assign that you get radiation treatment, or does it depend on the patient?

Related questions

DCIS, left breast, biopsy itself removed high grade cancer cells, lumpectomy path 100% cancer free. Radiation necessary? What about proton therapy?

Can elderly breast cancer patients still get radiation therapy?

Is tamoxifen safe and can I take it? I am a 67-year-old white female living alone. Last year i had early catch stage-1 breast cancer. I next had a lumpectomy and only one treatment of chemotherapy. I was scheduled for four treatments. The side affects

Im a breast cancer patient but half way through my heceptin. My doctor stopped my treatment because my heart is only working at 42 percent ?

I am a cancer patient and my doctor is out of town I am a breast cancer patient graded stage 2 carsanoma and had two breast tumors removed, a second for clear margins and five lymphnodes removed and were negative I have went through chemo, radiation, i go

Found in:

People also asked

Related topics

Disclaimer:

Get the Free App for Members

Get the Free App for Doctors

Product

Company

Work with Us

Why Trust Us