It's the best: A meniscus does not show on an x-ray. The history and physical exam can really help make the diagnosis. An arthrogram, dye and air injected into the knee used to be used to help decide if a tear is present or not. Painful test, often inconclusive, and frankly just about a lost art. An MRI is fast, painless, and rarely wrong. Mris are usually done prior to suggesting surgery.
Answered 3/28/2015
5.3k views
MRI is the best test: While ultrasound can show a meniscal tear it is has lower specificity and some false-positive diagnoses. Therefore, to avoid unnecessary arthroscopy an orthopedic surgeon will likely want an MRI for more detailed anatomical evaluation of the knee, confirmation of the diagnosis, as well as possibly finding additional pathology that might go undetected by ultrasound.
Answered 6/10/2014
5.3k views
Alternative: Although not as good in the evaluation of the ligaments and soft tissues surrounding the knee, an arthrogram with CT is almost as good for the diagnosis of meniscal tears and articular damage as an MRI. I disagree with other comments indicating an arthrogram is a painful procedure. Done properly, it is usually not more painful than a flu shot. Google "DrNefcy.com" and click on arthrogram advice.
Answered 3/31/2016
3.7k views
4 doctors weighed in across 2 answers
4 doctors weighed in across 2 answers
90,000 U.S. doctors in 147 specialties are here to answer your questions or offer you advice, prescriptions, and more.
Ask your question