A member asked:

The oncologist keeps insisting on chemo but i would rather have surgery only for breast cancer, i would like another opinion is it always necessary?

11 doctors weighed in across 4 answers

Autonomy: No one, not even the most zealous oncologist, can force you to do anything you don't want to do. Only a complete fool would refuse surgery or the equivalent for a breast cancer, but the decision to include chemotherapy weighs the benefits (which should be spelled out for you) against the unpleasantness and difficulties. Get two more opinions.

Answered 10/1/2019

5.5k views

Thank

Another opinion A+!: Your body is your own, and you make your own decisions. The treatment approach depends on many factors, including the extent and type of your tumor. You should get a second opinion, especially if you are uncertain of your own approach to your illness. Just as importantly, you should have a second opinion of your pathology (diagnosis), as the pathologist's interpretation is essential.

Answered 1/6/2014

5.5k views

Thank

Not always, but...: ...If you are not comfortable with your oncologist's opinion, you should get a second one. Unfortunately, surgery is rarely sufficient to treat breast cancer. More than half of all breast cancer patients require chemotherapy, and even more are given anti-estrogen therapy. The breast is but a battleground; the war is won or lost in the whole body. There is no better means for systemic rx than chemo.

Answered 9/22/2019

5.5k views

Thank

Chemotherapy: My influence "risks". Has your oncologist explained the benefit, what you "risk" by not taking the recommended treatment? If i were you, i'd seek two other opinions. On the other hand, if the oncotype test, and 3 doctors would *not* influence your decision, don't waste your money and their time. But remember the adage about "one treating themselves, has a fool for a patient.".

Answered 11/7/2012

5.5k views

Thank

Related Questions

Sponsored Content
HealthTap Medical Group does not endorse products or services. Sponsored content revenues support our mission to make health information free and accessible to all.Learn more