Are freakishly long toes normal?

Genetic: It could be the way you are unless there are any skeletal or collagen or other congenital abnormalities.

No: But being long will not affect anything.

Maybe: You already kind of answered your question. Calling them freakishly long suggests that they're not normal. Normal is subjective. In medicine we consider pain the criteria as a basis for whether things are normal or not, however often things like long toes can present with issues later (such as corns, calluses or in the worst case, arthritis of the joints). So basically it's all subjective.

Toes: Everything is subjective. In medicine pain is usually the criteria for intervention. You may think they are freakish , but have your podiatrist evaluate them