A member asked:

Is it true that if my baby can bend his finger or toe, it isn't broken?

12 doctors weighed in across 6 answers

No: Sometimes babies can bend digits that are broken, and sometimes won't bend digits that are not broken. Unfortunately, sometimes X-ray studies are needed to determine if bones are broken.

Answered 2/18/2015

6.7k views

Thank
Dr. Scott J. Wolfson answered

Specializes in Pediatrics

No: This is not a reliable idea. If everything around the break is intact, muscle, tendon, and ligaments, the finger or toe may work well but still be fractured (broken).

Answered 4/14/2011

6.6k views

Thank

No: No! a bone can be broken, but the muscles and tendons still work...Often a child will hold a broken bone still to protect it or prevent pain, but being able to move it is not a good test for fracture. Broken bones usually cause swelling and localized pain, but check with a doctor to be sure.

Answered 12/27/2014

6.6k views

Thank

No: Babies have lots of flexibility. Being able to bend a baby's finger or toe does not confirm that the finger or toe is unbroken. The doctor will also assess the amount of trauma (type of accident), the amount of pain on exam, and the amount of swelling. Also, x-rays may be needed.

Answered 5/29/2011

6.6k views

Thank
Dr. David Hettinger answered

Specializes in Podiatry

Not at all...: You can move an area with a broken bone. There will be increased pain, but it doesn't "self-splint" and stop moving.

Answered 7/18/2013

5k views

Thank

No: A broken/fractured digit on foot or hand can still be moved, usually with more pain. If you suspect a fracture suggest it gets checked.

Answered 7/18/2013

5k views

Thank

Related Questions