A member asked:

Dad's lung biopsy came back benign. he's having a 2nd biopsy done going in through his back. what are the chances this one will be benign too?

4 doctors weighed in across 3 answers

No way to tell: Lesions mimicking lung cancer include everything from old histoplasmosis (ubiquitous where i live) to stray dog heartworms. Or a first biopsy can be "benign" because they missed the cancer which is very common. Cherish each day with dad, and if the more definitive biopsy is benign, be happy.

Answered 2/3/2017

5.5k views

Thank
Dr. Travis Kidner answered

Specializes in Surgical Oncology

Hard to tell: It would be impossible to tell from the above information. The question they should ask when a biopsy comes back negative is whether the lesion in question was actually sampled or did they sample normal tissue beside the lesion in question.

Answered 10/23/2017

5.4k views

Thank
Dr. Michael Sanders answered

Specializes in Pulmonology

No way of knowing: We would need to know the case and be able to review imaging to even make a guess. Lung biopsies can be done and still not come up with a diagnosis.

Answered 6/5/2017

669 views

Thank

Related Questions

A member asked:

Should a biopsy be done on the lung if has pneumonia?

A doctor has provided 1 answer