September 2, 2020

Contraception

The prescription spermicide Phexxi is the newcomer to the group, and may be suitable for people who want a non-hormonal method, used on an as-needed basis, with usage controlled by the woman, plus tolerance of a higher failure rate. I've included information about Phexxi in the following table, to introduce you to its characteristics. You can read more about Phexxi here.

Needs a visit to a healthcare provider for a procedure:

Method

Perfect Use (%)

Typical Use (%)

Negatives

Notes

Progestin implant - Nexplanon, Implanon

0.1

Irregular vaginal bleeding, mood changes, or changes in sex drive can happen.

Lasts 3 years.

Progestin IUD - Mirena, Kyleena, Liletta, Skyla

0.2

Irregular vaginal bleeding, mood changes, skin problems, or breast tenderness can happen. Rare risk of ectopic pregnancy or the IUD poking through the uterus.

Lasts 5, 5, 6, 3 years, respectively.

Copper IUD - Paragard (nonhormonal)

0.8

Heavier periods can happen. Rare risk of ectopic pregnancy or the IUD poking through the uterus.

Lasts 10 years. Can use as Emergency Contraception within 5 days of sex.

Progestin injection - Depo-Provera (Noristerat and Sayana Press unavailable in the US)

4

Irregular vaginal bleeding, mood changes, weight gain, or changes in sex drive can happen.

Lasts 3 months. Fertility takes an average of 6 months to return (range of 0-12 months).

A provider can evaluate and write a prescription:

Methods

Perfect Use (%)

Typical Use (%)

Negatives

Notes

Combination Pill, Patch, or Vaginal Ring (progestin plus estrogen)

0.3

7

Moodiness, hunger, nausea, or lower sex drive can happen. Not suitable if there is smoking, high blood pressure, obesity, risk of blood clots.

Take 1 pill each day, or change the patch each week, or change the ring each month.

Mini Pill (progestin)

0.3

Irregular vaginal bleeding, mood changes, or changes in sex drive can happen.

Take 1 pill each day around the same time.

Diaphragm or Cervical Cap

6

17

Must combine with a spermicide and insert before sex.

Leave diaphragm or cervical cap in for 6 hours after sex.

Phexxi spermicide (formerly named Amphora)

7% (in 7 months)

14% (in 7 months)

Typical-use failure rate estimated above 20% in 12 months. Not suitable for women with recurrent UTI's or urinary tract abnormalities.

Lasts 1 hour or 1 ejaculation, whichever is sooner. Approved by FDA in May 2020.

Over-the-counter, non-prescription:

Methods

Perfect Use (%)

Typical Use (%)

Negatives

Notes

Condom (male)

2

13

Female condom

5

21

Typical failure rate above 20%

Spermicide (excludes Phexxi)

18

21

Must insert 10-15 minutes before sex. Typical failure rate above 20%.

Lasts 1 hour or 1 ejaculation. Leave spermicide in for at least 6 hours after sex.

Other alternatives:

Methods

Perfect Use (%)

Typical Use (%)

Negatives

Notes

Withdrawal (pull penis out)

4

22

Requires extreme self-control. Typical failure rate above 20%

Fertility Awareness (track ovulation)

0.4

23

Can be tricky to learn. Typical failure rate above 20%

Check each day the temperature and cervical mucus thickness.

Vasectomy

0.5

Minor surgery. Permanent sterilization.

Lasts forever.

Tubal Ligation

0.2

Minor surgery. Permanent sterilization.

Lasts forever.

Emergency Contraception (levonorgestrel PlanB, ulipristal Ella, copper IUD Paragard)

2% for Ella and 3% for PlanB, for one episode

Plan B is OTC and decreases in effectiveness if used on days 4 or 5 after sex. Ella and PlanB failure rates increase with obesity, and may double if BMI >= 30.

Use within 5 days of sex.

No contraceptive method used

85

85

Can end up pregnant every year.

Definitions:

  • Failure rate
    Usually defined as the percentage of women who get pregnant during their first year of using the contraceptive method.
  • Failure rate range
    When shown as a range, the lower number represents Perfect Use and the higher number is for Typical Use failure rates.
  • Perfect use
    Represents pregnancies that occurred in women even though they always used their contraception correctly and consistently.
  • Typical use
    Represents how the average person uses contraception. These rates apply to women who became pregnant while not always using the contraception correctly or consistently. Many people find it challenging to always use contraception correctly.

About Phexxi:

Medication Form & Strength:

  • lactic acid 18mg, citric acid 10mg, potassium bitartrate 4mg per gram.
  • 5g prefilled single-dose vaginal gel applicator.
  • 12 applicators per box, estimated price $265 per box.

Indication:

  • For prevention of pregnancy in females of reproductive potential for use as an on-demand contraceptive method:
    • Apply 1 prefilled applicator (5 grams) vaginally immediately before or up to 1 hour before each act of vaginal intercourse.
    • If more than 1 act of vaginal intercourse occurs within that 1 hour, an additional dose must be applied.

Dosing considerations:

  • May be used concomitantly with hormonal contraceptives; latex, polyurethane, or polyisoprene condoms; or vaginal diaphragms.
  • AVOID use with vaginal rings.
  • May be used concomitantly with other products for vaginal infections, including miconazole, metronidazole, or tioconazole.
  • NOT effective for prevention of pregnancy when applied after intercourse.

Drug interactions:

  • No interactions found.

Adverse effects:

  • >10%. ...
  • Vulvovaginal burning sensation (18%).
  • Vulvovaginal pruritus (14.5%).
  • 1-10%. ...
  • Local discomfort in male partners (9.8%).
  • Vulvovaginal mycotic infection (9.1%).
  • Urinary tract infection (UTI) (9%).
  • Vulvovaginal discomfort (9%).
  • Bacterial vaginosis (8.4%).
  • Vaginal discharge (5.5%).
  • Genital discomfort (4.1%).
  • Dysuria (3.1%).
  • Vulvovaginal pain (2.1%).

Contraindications:

  • None.

Cautions:

  • Discontinue if hypersensitivity reactions develops.
  • Cystitis, pyelonephritis, or other upper UTI may occur.
  • AVOID use of in females of reproductive potential with a history of recurrent UTI or urinary tract abnormalities.

Pregnancy & lactation:

  • DO NOT use during pregnancy.
  • No data available with the use in pregnant females or animals.
  • No data available on the presence of lactic acid, citric acid, and potassium bitartrate or their metabolites in human milk, or effects on breastfeeding or milk production.

Mechanism of action:

  • Regulates vaginal pH within the normal range of 3.5–4.5, even in the presence of semen, which normally raises the vaginal pH to 7–8.
    • Maintains an acidic environment that is inhospitable to sperm, as well as to certain viral and bacterial pathogens associated with STI's, but is integral to the survival of healthy bacteria in the vagina.

Pharmacokinetics:

  • Pharmacokinetic studies in humans have not been performed.
  • Systemic exposures of lactic acid, citric acid, and potassium bitartrate following vaginal administration are not expected to lead to safety concerns.

Administration, storage:

  • May use during any part of the menstrual cycle.
  • May use as soon as it is safe to resume vaginal intercourse after childbirth, abortion, or miscarriage.
  • Store in the original foil pack at room temperature 20-25ºC (68-77ºF); excursions permitted to 15-30ºC (59-86ºF).

References: