5 doctors weighed in:
Had low back pain for ten years, over last year it has been constant and gets worse with activities. Time for surgery?
5 doctors weighed in

Dr. Norman Marcus
Pain Management
2 doctors agree
In brief: No
Surgery is considered for back pain if you have cauda equina syndrome, which is pain radiating from your back down your leg to your toes, accompanied by numbness, weakness, muscle loss, diminished reflexes and problems controlling urine, or if you have imaging documented spinal instability or compression of the spinal cord or nerve roots (spinal stenosis).
Non-radiating back pain doesn't qualify.

In brief: No
Surgery is considered for back pain if you have cauda equina syndrome, which is pain radiating from your back down your leg to your toes, accompanied by numbness, weakness, muscle loss, diminished reflexes and problems controlling urine, or if you have imaging documented spinal instability or compression of the spinal cord or nerve roots (spinal stenosis).
Non-radiating back pain doesn't qualify.
Dr. Norman Marcus
Dr. Norman Marcus
Thank
Dr. Alexandre De Moura
Orthopedic Surgery - Spine
In brief: Time for surgery
If the pain is severe and you can no longer tolerate it than surgery may be an option.
Pure mechanical back is an indication for spinal surgery. If your orthopaedic spine surgeon can identify the source of your pain be it the disc, facet joint etc....Than a fusion is an excellent surgical option if done correctly. 'you don't have to have just neurological deficits for surgical intervention.

In brief: Time for surgery
If the pain is severe and you can no longer tolerate it than surgery may be an option.
Pure mechanical back is an indication for spinal surgery. If your orthopaedic spine surgeon can identify the source of your pain be it the disc, facet joint etc....Than a fusion is an excellent surgical option if done correctly. 'you don't have to have just neurological deficits for surgical intervention.
Dr. Alexandre De Moura
Dr. Alexandre De Moura
Thank
Dr. Craig Morton
Physical & Rehabilitation Medicine
In brief: Not necessarily
You need to start by seeing a physician.
There are many causes of low back pain. Most cases of mechanical low back pain (even chronic pain) can be treated conservatively.

In brief: Not necessarily
You need to start by seeing a physician.
There are many causes of low back pain. Most cases of mechanical low back pain (even chronic pain) can be treated conservatively.
Dr. Craig Morton
Dr. Craig Morton
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Eric Weisman
Board Certified, Neurology
32 years in practice
9M people helped
Continue
107,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors