18 doctors weighed in:

How can I defferintiate between OCD thoughts and negative thoughts?

18 doctors weighed in
5 doctors agree

In brief: O won't stop

Obsessive thoughts need not be negative, though their persistence is uncomfortable.
For example, a common obsession is counting. Once begun, one "must" count to 20, say. Obsessive thoughts that are negative -- imagining doing something dire -- generally channel other anxieties, and actually alleviate them somewhat, and only briefly. Their "attraction" is the thought, "what if i act"?

In brief: O won't stop

Obsessive thoughts need not be negative, though their persistence is uncomfortable.
For example, a common obsession is counting. Once begun, one "must" count to 20, say. Obsessive thoughts that are negative -- imagining doing something dire -- generally channel other anxieties, and actually alleviate them somewhat, and only briefly. Their "attraction" is the thought, "what if i act"?
Dr. Jeffrey Satinover
Dr. Jeffrey Satinover
Thank
Justin Fuehrer
Emergency Medicine
5 doctors agree

In brief: OCD requires action

Generally, OCD requires some type of action in order to alleviate the bad thought.
Whether this is rechecking to make sure the oven is off multiple times or washing hands multiple times even when already clean, it does not matter the specific action so long as it is done to alleviate the thought process.

In brief: OCD requires action

Generally, OCD requires some type of action in order to alleviate the bad thought.
Whether this is rechecking to make sure the oven is off multiple times or washing hands multiple times even when already clean, it does not matter the specific action so long as it is done to alleviate the thought process.
Justin Fuehrer
Justin Fuehrer
Answer assisted by Justin Fuehrer, Medical Student
Thank
Dr. Douglas Bey
Psychiatry
3 doctors agree

In brief: Interesting question

Obsessive thoughts r irrational & can b negative.
Negative rumination that goes with depression can be irrational--do you have symptoms of clinical depression along with the thoughts? Do you have compulsive behaviors? These other symptoms may help u make the distinction.

In brief: Interesting question

Obsessive thoughts r irrational & can b negative.
Negative rumination that goes with depression can be irrational--do you have symptoms of clinical depression along with the thoughts? Do you have compulsive behaviors? These other symptoms may help u make the distinction.
Dr. Douglas Bey
Dr. Douglas Bey
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Douglas Bey
Usually intrusive thoughts r the most upsetting ie mothers may think harm their babies --Poe called it the imp of perverse like the urge to jump up & yell in churchchurch
Dr. Timothy Re
Clinical Psychology
2 doctors agree

In brief: Intrusive and anxiet

Negative thoughts are a broader category of thinking that leads to personality and many other difficulties.
Ocd thoughts almost always cause anxiety and are more unwanted and intrusive. They tend to be associated with vulnerabilities we have.

In brief: Intrusive and anxiet

Negative thoughts are a broader category of thinking that leads to personality and many other difficulties.
Ocd thoughts almost always cause anxiety and are more unwanted and intrusive. They tend to be associated with vulnerabilities we have.
Dr. Timothy Re
Dr. Timothy Re
Thank
Dr. Max Haque
Psychiatry
2 doctors agree

In brief: Different causes

Ocd or obsessive compulsive thoughts are those that cause severe anxiety unless you carry out the act__for example, repeatedly checking to see if your door is locked, washing your hands over and over to get rid of germs, etc.
Negative thoughts are self-destructive in nature that can result in severe guilty, hopeless, helpless or useless feelings, and finally even suicidal thoughts.

In brief: Different causes

Ocd or obsessive compulsive thoughts are those that cause severe anxiety unless you carry out the act__for example, repeatedly checking to see if your door is locked, washing your hands over and over to get rid of germs, etc.
Negative thoughts are self-destructive in nature that can result in severe guilty, hopeless, helpless or useless feelings, and finally even suicidal thoughts.
Dr. Max Haque
Dr. Max Haque
Thank
Dr. Susan Uhrich
Psychiatry
2 doctors agree

In brief: Tough one

In general, OCD thoughts are negative thoughts, but not all negative thoughts are OCD thoughts.
We all have the occasional negative thought, but a constant barrage of them is not good, OCD or not.

In brief: Tough one

In general, OCD thoughts are negative thoughts, but not all negative thoughts are OCD thoughts.
We all have the occasional negative thought, but a constant barrage of them is not good, OCD or not.
Dr. Susan Uhrich
Dr. Susan Uhrich
Thank
David Miller
Family Medicine
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Compulsion

The hallmark of obsessive-compulsive disorder is compulsive actions brought on by obsessive thoughts.
It is worrisome thoughts of infections or irons burning down the house or car lights running down the battery that cause compulsive actions. This is very different from simple negative thoughts.

In brief: Compulsion

The hallmark of obsessive-compulsive disorder is compulsive actions brought on by obsessive thoughts.
It is worrisome thoughts of infections or irons burning down the house or car lights running down the battery that cause compulsive actions. This is very different from simple negative thoughts.
David Miller
David Miller
Answer assisted by David Miller, Medical Student
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Peter Kurzweil
Board Certified,
46 years in practice
16M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors