4 doctors weighed in:
Is it a good idea to discipline my baby?
4 doctors weighed in

Dr. James Ferguson
Pediatrics
1 doctor agrees
In brief: No
The definition of discipline varies with each person in technique and purpose.
To me the term baby means a totaly dependent pre-toddler.While it is realistic to redirect infants, use body language, simple time out & basic communication to infer "no", the idea of punitive dicipline in this age group makes my skin crawl. Mobile todlers require more limit setting & are likely to understand it more.

In brief: No
The definition of discipline varies with each person in technique and purpose.
To me the term baby means a totaly dependent pre-toddler.While it is realistic to redirect infants, use body language, simple time out & basic communication to infer "no", the idea of punitive dicipline in this age group makes my skin crawl. Mobile todlers require more limit setting & are likely to understand it more.
Dr. James Ferguson
Dr. James Ferguson
Thank
Dr. Michael Amster
Pediatrics
1 doctor agrees
In brief: Yes
Remember, discipline means teaching to your rules.
It is not "being punitive". That's key. Should you yell at, smack or punish your baby? No. That won't be effective. Should you discipline them? Sure. If they are doing behaviors that you want to encourage, then you should pay more attention. Early on, positive reinforcement works best. Later, time outs work as negative reinforcement.

In brief: Yes
Remember, discipline means teaching to your rules.
It is not "being punitive". That's key. Should you yell at, smack or punish your baby? No. That won't be effective. Should you discipline them? Sure. If they are doing behaviors that you want to encourage, then you should pay more attention. Early on, positive reinforcement works best. Later, time outs work as negative reinforcement.
Dr. Michael Amster
Dr. Michael Amster
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Jonathan Jassey
Board Certified, Pediatrics
13 years in practice
1M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors