20 doctors weighed in:

Can an abdominal hernia rupture by pushing it back in?

20 doctors weighed in
11 doctors agree

In brief: Stuck hernia?

It will usually not ruptue.
If it hurts and there is reddness around the area do not try to push it back in because the there might be bowel stuck and it can be damaged. So best thing to do is go to an emergency room if a hernia gets "stuck".

In brief: Stuck hernia?

It will usually not ruptue.
If it hurts and there is reddness around the area do not try to push it back in because the there might be bowel stuck and it can be damaged. So best thing to do is go to an emergency room if a hernia gets "stuck".
Dr. Alexander Barkan
Dr. Alexander Barkan
Thank
Dr. Camil Sader
Surgery
6 doctors agree

In brief: Unusually so

Hernias typically should not rupture when pushed back in.
In fact, it is recommended that they remain in so they do not strangulate. Rupture of the contents of a hernia, especially if it's intestine, could happen when strangulation ensues. That's when the blood supply is choked and the tissue dies. Hernias that cannot be reduced (pushed back in) need to be addressed by a surgeon urgently.

In brief: Unusually so

Hernias typically should not rupture when pushed back in.
In fact, it is recommended that they remain in so they do not strangulate. Rupture of the contents of a hernia, especially if it's intestine, could happen when strangulation ensues. That's when the blood supply is choked and the tissue dies. Hernias that cannot be reduced (pushed back in) need to be addressed by a surgeon urgently.
Dr. Camil Sader
Dr. Camil Sader
Thank
5 doctors agree

In brief: No

Reducing an abdominal hernia is safe, as long as it moves freely and can be reduced without excessive force.
If it is "stuck", then you need to see a surgeon immediately.

In brief: No

Reducing an abdominal hernia is safe, as long as it moves freely and can be reduced without excessive force.
If it is "stuck", then you need to see a surgeon immediately.
Dr. Sharmila Dissanaike
Dr. Sharmila Dissanaike
Thank
4 doctors agree

In brief: Possibly

A hernia can rupture if the protruding contents are pushed back in, but it does not happen often.
The hernia stays the same size, but what comes through (bowel or fat) may swell and cause pain. If it swells too much it becomes painful. If you cannot push it back in you need to go to the er now. If they can't push it back in, you have to have it fixed before further problems develop.

In brief: Possibly

A hernia can rupture if the protruding contents are pushed back in, but it does not happen often.
The hernia stays the same size, but what comes through (bowel or fat) may swell and cause pain. If it swells too much it becomes painful. If you cannot push it back in you need to go to the er now. If they can't push it back in, you have to have it fixed before further problems develop.
Dr. Scott Grover
Dr. Scott Grover
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Crystal Twynham
Board Certified, Surgery
29 years in practice
938K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors