16 doctors weighed in:

My newborn baby is having surgery. The anesthesiologist wants to do spinal anesthesia. Says, gen anesthesia not good for little brain. Is spinal safe?

16 doctors weighed in
Dr. Richard Pollard
Anesthesiology
4 doctors agree

In brief: Yes, but

The spinal is a safe anesthetic for a pediatric patient.
I have found that the surgeons do not like the fact that the patient is still wiggling while they work, but that is personal. I am not sure that i completely agree with the comments of my colleague about anesthesia and the brain, but that is a different discussion.

In brief: Yes, but

The spinal is a safe anesthetic for a pediatric patient.
I have found that the surgeons do not like the fact that the patient is still wiggling while they work, but that is personal. I am not sure that i completely agree with the comments of my colleague about anesthesia and the brain, but that is a different discussion.
Dr. Richard Pollard
Dr. Richard Pollard
Thank
Dr. John Stork
Anesthesiology
3 doctors agree

In brief: Spinal OK

Recent animal studies raise concerns that some anesthetics might interfere with brain development.
However we know that surgery without anesthesia is very damaging, so anesthesia may be necessary. In young infants surgery should be delayed until older unless absolutely needed. For the right kind of surgery, a spinal or regional or local anesthesia is a way to avoid the more toxic agents.

In brief: Spinal OK

Recent animal studies raise concerns that some anesthetics might interfere with brain development.
However we know that surgery without anesthesia is very damaging, so anesthesia may be necessary. In young infants surgery should be delayed until older unless absolutely needed. For the right kind of surgery, a spinal or regional or local anesthesia is a way to avoid the more toxic agents.
Dr. John Stork
Dr. John Stork
Thank
Dr. David Edsall
Anesthesiology
3 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

Ask how many cases like this the anesthesiologist has done.
If < 10 make sure there is backup help. Spinal seems better but studies are few wtihout long term outcomes.

In brief: Yes

Ask how many cases like this the anesthesiologist has done.
If < 10 make sure there is backup help. Spinal seems better but studies are few wtihout long term outcomes.
Dr. David Edsall
Dr. David Edsall
Thank
Dr. Nikolaos Zacharias
Obstetrics & Gynecology - Maternal Fetal Medicine
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Big hospital

Trust hospitals with large numbers of similar procedures.
If your anesthesiologist and pediatric surgeon both agree on this plan and you are at a tertiary care center, go for it.

In brief: Big hospital

Trust hospitals with large numbers of similar procedures.
If your anesthesiologist and pediatric surgeon both agree on this plan and you are at a tertiary care center, go for it.
Dr. Nikolaos Zacharias
Dr. Nikolaos Zacharias
Thank
Dr. Scott Mackinnon
Anesthesiology

In brief: Yes

Important to have an experienced pediatric anesthesiologist.
Especially in newborn where respiratory center not fully matured, a primary spinal technique is very safe, especially in short procedure. Baby should do fine. Rest assured, your child will be fully monitored in the same fashion as a general and he/she will experience no pain.

In brief: Yes

Important to have an experienced pediatric anesthesiologist.
Especially in newborn where respiratory center not fully matured, a primary spinal technique is very safe, especially in short procedure. Baby should do fine. Rest assured, your child will be fully monitored in the same fashion as a general and he/she will experience no pain.
Dr. Scott Mackinnon
Dr. Scott Mackinnon
Thank
Dr. Rita Agarwal
Anesthesiology

In brief: Spinal is safe

Yes, spinal is very safe.
General anesthesia is also safe, but their are questions that are currently being investigated regarding the effects of anesthesai (and surgery and stress) on the developing brain.

In brief: Spinal is safe

Yes, spinal is very safe.
General anesthesia is also safe, but their are questions that are currently being investigated regarding the effects of anesthesai (and surgery and stress) on the developing brain.
Dr. Rita Agarwal
Dr. Rita Agarwal
Thank
Dr. Kamel Ghandour
Anesthesiology

In brief: Yes!

Hello ! i think that you can ask more questions.
I'm the assistant chief & i encourage pre-anesthesia phone calls from patients' parents. Ask them! pediatric anesthesiologists are used to questions from mothers. We customize the anesthesia for the child & the surgery to minimize risk. Spinal anesthesia can be safe & so is a general anesthesia... It all depends on what your child needs!

In brief: Yes!

Hello ! i think that you can ask more questions.
I'm the assistant chief & i encourage pre-anesthesia phone calls from patients' parents. Ask them! pediatric anesthesiologists are used to questions from mothers. We customize the anesthesia for the child & the surgery to minimize risk. Spinal anesthesia can be safe & so is a general anesthesia... It all depends on what your child needs!
Dr. Kamel Ghandour
Dr. Kamel Ghandour
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Mark Pack
Board Certified, Surgery
27 years in practice
3M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors