6 doctors weighed in:

Whats better for COPD a nebulizer or an inhaler?

6 doctors weighed in
Dr. Carlo Hatem
Internal Medicine - Pulmonary Critical Care
3 doctors agree

In brief: Equivalent

A nebulizer is used when the person is not able to use the inhaler properly.
When used the proper way both deliver the right amount of medication. A nebulizer is less portable and takes more time to deliver (10 to 15 minutes), usually requires a power plug. An inhaler is very handy, fits in a pocket or a small purse. And then, there is personal preference.

In brief: Equivalent

A nebulizer is used when the person is not able to use the inhaler properly.
When used the proper way both deliver the right amount of medication. A nebulizer is less portable and takes more time to deliver (10 to 15 minutes), usually requires a power plug. An inhaler is very handy, fits in a pocket or a small purse. And then, there is personal preference.
Dr. Carlo Hatem
Dr. Carlo Hatem
Thank
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Depends

I hate giving a "depends" answer but this is what it is.
Inhalers are convenient to use and carry. Sometimes, the patient cannot coordinate inhalations and hand activation very well and the drug is not getting to the lungs. Nebulizers require the patient to just breathe and the drug is dispersed in the "mist". Nebulizers have a high maintenance profile to prevent contamination. Good Luck

In brief: Depends

I hate giving a "depends" answer but this is what it is.
Inhalers are convenient to use and carry. Sometimes, the patient cannot coordinate inhalations and hand activation very well and the drug is not getting to the lungs. Nebulizers require the patient to just breathe and the drug is dispersed in the "mist". Nebulizers have a high maintenance profile to prevent contamination. Good Luck
Dr. Richard Williams
Dr. Richard Williams
Thank
Dr. Mark Avdalovic
Internal Medicine - Pulmonary Critical Care

In brief: Depends

Patient who have mild COPD can generate a forceful inward breath and will do well with an inhaler while patients with advnaced COPD sometimes find the nebuiizer easier to use.
Little children tend to do better with a nebulizer.

In brief: Depends

Patient who have mild COPD can generate a forceful inward breath and will do well with an inhaler while patients with advnaced COPD sometimes find the nebuiizer easier to use.
Little children tend to do better with a nebulizer.
Dr. Mark Avdalovic
Dr. Mark Avdalovic
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Aaron Milstone
Board Certified, Internal Medicine - Pulmonology
23 years in practice
1M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors