5 doctors weighed in:
What is better for quick weight loss: treadmill or elliptical?
5 doctors weighed in

Dr. Vasu Brown
Wound care
2 doctors agree
In brief: Depends
A treadmill will cost more due to higher manufacturing costs, the calories burnt between the machines is almost identical, the joint impact on a treadmill will be greater compared to a cross trainer and finally a cross trainer will be quieter compared to a treadmill.
So there are the facts, you should analyze and then make up your own mind.

In brief: Depends
A treadmill will cost more due to higher manufacturing costs, the calories burnt between the machines is almost identical, the joint impact on a treadmill will be greater compared to a cross trainer and finally a cross trainer will be quieter compared to a treadmill.
So there are the facts, you should analyze and then make up your own mind.
Dr. Vasu Brown
Dr. Vasu Brown
Thank
Dr. Kenneth Cheng
Family Medicine
2 doctors agree
In brief: Both
Both treadmill and elliptical are about equal in the calories burned per hour of exercise, depending on the speed, elevation and resistance settings.
The elliptical may be easier on the knees and hips; the treadmill better mimics running or walking. In my opinion, both are equal.

In brief: Both
Both treadmill and elliptical are about equal in the calories burned per hour of exercise, depending on the speed, elevation and resistance settings.
The elliptical may be easier on the knees and hips; the treadmill better mimics running or walking. In my opinion, both are equal.
Dr. Kenneth Cheng
Dr. Kenneth Cheng
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Marsha Davis
Board Certified, Internal Medicine
24 years in practice
67M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors