5 doctors weighed in:
The doctor said that my child has an "innocent murmur, " is there any chance that this is an asd?
5 doctors weighed in

Dr. William Scott
Pediatrics - Cardiology
1 doctor agrees
In brief: Yes
Most commonly an ASD can be distinguished from an innocent murmur by listening alone.
There are rare exceptions.

In brief: Yes
Most commonly an ASD can be distinguished from an innocent murmur by listening alone.
There are rare exceptions.
Dr. William Scott
Dr. William Scott
Thank
Dr. Volkan Tuzcu
Pediatrics - Cardiology
In brief: Asd
If he did an echocardiogram no there is no chance, if he only listened there's a very small chance a cardiologist may miss a small ASD

In brief: Asd
If he did an echocardiogram no there is no chance, if he only listened there's a very small chance a cardiologist may miss a small ASD
Dr. Volkan Tuzcu
Dr. Volkan Tuzcu
Thank
Dr. Sarosh Batlivala
Pediatrics - Cardiology
In brief: Possible but...
An innocent murmur is by definition "innocent".
But we (doctor's) are human and mistakes can be made. However, diagnosing an ASD in a child is generally not an emergency. Many, many children have innocent murmurs. Though a significant ASD may sound "innocent" early in age, the murmur and other heart sounds will change over time. If your pediatrician remains concerned then you can be referred.

In brief: Possible but...
An innocent murmur is by definition "innocent".
But we (doctor's) are human and mistakes can be made. However, diagnosing an ASD in a child is generally not an emergency. Many, many children have innocent murmurs. Though a significant ASD may sound "innocent" early in age, the murmur and other heart sounds will change over time. If your pediatrician remains concerned then you can be referred.
Dr. Sarosh Batlivala
Dr. Sarosh Batlivala
Thank
Dr. James Ferguson
Pediatrics
In brief: Depends
The ASD is often diagnosed clinically by a fixed splitting of heart sounds rather than a murmur. Most of what are lumped into the term innocent murmurs are not caused by any structural heart problem. The most common has a twanging string noise like a base fiddle, but there are others.
If the issue bothers you a echocardiogram could confirm the dx.

In brief: Depends
The ASD is often diagnosed clinically by a fixed splitting of heart sounds rather than a murmur. Most of what are lumped into the term innocent murmurs are not caused by any structural heart problem. The most common has a twanging string noise like a base fiddle, but there are others.
If the issue bothers you a echocardiogram could confirm the dx.
Dr. James Ferguson
Dr. James Ferguson
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Umesh Patel
Board Certified, Internal Medicine - Cardiology
38 years in practice
1M people helped
Continue
107,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors