16 doctors weighed in:

Am i better off hiding the real extent of my psychiatric problems from psychiatrists? I've had major depression for much of my life, including a few hospitalizations. After a suicide attempt five years ago, my then-psychiatrist asked me to seek psychiatri

16 doctors weighed in
Dr. Joy Jackson
Family Medicine
6 doctors agree

In brief: Full

Full disclosure of your history is key to successful treatment.
Be completely honest with your doctor about your past, your issues with previous doctors, and what you think went wrong. Hopefully the doctor will be able to sort through all the issues and come up with an appropriate treatment plan; if not then ask for a direct referral to someone who can help you. All the best.

In brief: Full

Full disclosure of your history is key to successful treatment.
Be completely honest with your doctor about your past, your issues with previous doctors, and what you think went wrong. Hopefully the doctor will be able to sort through all the issues and come up with an appropriate treatment plan; if not then ask for a direct referral to someone who can help you. All the best.
Dr. Joy Jackson
Dr. Joy Jackson
Thank
Dr. Peter Zafirides
Psychiatry
4 doctors agree

In brief: Don't Hide Anything!

Member: you should never feel you have to hide anything from your psychiatrist.
If you get that feeling, look for a new doctor. Period. We should be providing you with a safe and open environment, free of judgement. I am sorry for your past experience, but we are here to serve you as your doctors. It is our privilege, not the other way around. I hope that helps! -- dr. Z (the healthy mind).

In brief: Don't Hide Anything!

Member: you should never feel you have to hide anything from your psychiatrist.
If you get that feeling, look for a new doctor. Period. We should be providing you with a safe and open environment, free of judgement. I am sorry for your past experience, but we are here to serve you as your doctors. It is our privilege, not the other way around. I hope that helps! -- dr. Z (the healthy mind).
Dr. Peter Zafirides
Dr. Peter Zafirides
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Bassam Amawi
I agree , be honest and open with U psychiatrist
Dr. Daryl Tanski
Psychiatry
3 doctors agree

In brief: Why

Would you hide your heart symptoms from your cardiologist ? Your doctor needs to know the extent of your condition the best be able to help you.

In brief: Why

Would you hide your heart symptoms from your cardiologist ? Your doctor needs to know the extent of your condition the best be able to help you.
Dr. Daryl Tanski
Dr. Daryl Tanski
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Jane Steiner
Absolutely, you need to be as truthful as possible with your psychiatrist!
Dr. John Moranville
Psychiatry
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Absolutely not

We can't help you if you hide anything and that is what we are here for. As others have noted if you feel uncomforatable about talking about anything find another doctor. Most of us really care or we would not be doing what we do.
Good luck! depression is a treatable condition and you deserve to acheive full remission of your symptoms.

In brief: Absolutely not

We can't help you if you hide anything and that is what we are here for. As others have noted if you feel uncomforatable about talking about anything find another doctor. Most of us really care or we would not be doing what we do.
Good luck! depression is a treatable condition and you deserve to acheive full remission of your symptoms.
Dr. John Moranville
Dr. John Moranville
Thank
Dr. Peter O'Donnell
Clinical Psychology

In brief: Trust & openness

The basis of any relationship is trust.
It is important that you build on that, rather than deceit. How can some one get to know &help you, if you do not open up, or be truthful. Being able to learn to manage your condition, and live more fully is an important goal in treatment. If you have concerns, address those concerns.

In brief: Trust & openness

The basis of any relationship is trust.
It is important that you build on that, rather than deceit. How can some one get to know &help you, if you do not open up, or be truthful. Being able to learn to manage your condition, and live more fully is an important goal in treatment. If you have concerns, address those concerns.
Dr. Peter O'Donnell
Dr. Peter O'Donnell
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Bennett Machanic
Board Certified, Neurology
49 years in practice
56M people helped
Continue
111,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors