5 doctors weighed in:

Is it worth it for an eighty-seven year old alzheimer's patient to have surgery to clear a blocked carotid artery?

5 doctors weighed in
Dr. James Ferguson
Pediatrics
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Ethical issues

From one vantage point, withholding a common procedure because of a disability is bad.
However, any intervention with a level of risk must be worth while to the quality of life of the patient. If it just prolongs the process of dying, without an improvement of life, it is unfair to all involved.

In brief: Ethical issues

From one vantage point, withholding a common procedure because of a disability is bad.
However, any intervention with a level of risk must be worth while to the quality of life of the patient. If it just prolongs the process of dying, without an improvement of life, it is unfair to all involved.
Dr. James Ferguson
Dr. James Ferguson
Thank
Dr. Maureen Nash
Psychiatry - Geriatric
1 doctor agrees

In brief: No 1 answer fits all

Every surgery has risks and benefits.
Each specific person and their particular health history also bring benefits and risks to the discussion. Answering this question for any particular person is best done with honest open communication discussing all of the risks and benefits between the healthcare team and the person most effected.

In brief: No 1 answer fits all

Every surgery has risks and benefits.
Each specific person and their particular health history also bring benefits and risks to the discussion. Answering this question for any particular person is best done with honest open communication discussing all of the risks and benefits between the healthcare team and the person most effected.
Dr. Maureen Nash
Dr. Maureen Nash
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Michael Korona
If the patient is severely debilitated, not good to intervene.
Dr. Barry Rosen
Surgery

In brief: Age & Surgery

Every operation is approached with consideration of the risks vs.
Benefits. We are also taught to consider one's physiologic age rather than any set number. As a surgeon, i would have a hard time offering elective surgery to someone with (advanced) alzheimer's disease unless i knew it would improve their quality of life.

In brief: Age & Surgery

Every operation is approached with consideration of the risks vs.
Benefits. We are also taught to consider one's physiologic age rather than any set number. As a surgeon, i would have a hard time offering elective surgery to someone with (advanced) alzheimer's disease unless i knew it would improve their quality of life.
Dr. Barry Rosen
Dr. Barry Rosen
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Marsha Davis
Board Certified, Internal Medicine
24 years in practice
67M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors