3 doctors weighed in:
Is following a ketogenic diet as effective as surgery for epilepsy?
3 doctors weighed in

Dr. William Singer
Pediatrics - Neurology
1 doctor agrees
In brief: Diet vs surgery
The ketogenic diet and surgery are two approaches to reduce or control seizures.
Surgery is directed at localized areas of brain from which seizures are triggered. The ketogenic diet is most often used for medication resistent seizures that are generalized forms of epilepsy or seizure syndromes. They are not usuallly interchangeable.

In brief: Diet vs surgery
The ketogenic diet and surgery are two approaches to reduce or control seizures.
Surgery is directed at localized areas of brain from which seizures are triggered. The ketogenic diet is most often used for medication resistent seizures that are generalized forms of epilepsy or seizure syndromes. They are not usuallly interchangeable.
Dr. William Singer
Dr. William Singer
Thank
Dr. Seth Zeidman
Neurosurgery
In brief: For some children
Many children who go on a ketogenic diet have already tried multiple anti-convulsion medications without effective seizure control or with intolerable side effects.
About a third of children who go on this diet become completely seizure-free. It isn't for everyone and it requires close monitoring, supervision and often vitamin and mineral supplementation but it really does work for many children.

In brief: For some children
Many children who go on a ketogenic diet have already tried multiple anti-convulsion medications without effective seizure control or with intolerable side effects.
About a third of children who go on this diet become completely seizure-free. It isn't for everyone and it requires close monitoring, supervision and often vitamin and mineral supplementation but it really does work for many children.
Dr. Seth Zeidman
Dr. Seth Zeidman
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Buck Parker
Board Certified, Surgery
13 years in practice
467K people helped
Continue
107,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors