3 doctors weighed in:
Are there benefits in having knee arthroscopic surgery for arthritis?
3 doctors weighed in

Dr. Jay Rosenfeld
Physical & Rehabilitation Medicine
1 doctor agrees
In brief: Possibly
There was a studydone in texas a few years ago that suggested that arthroscopy forknee problems was not more effective than placebo.
Having said that I have seen people improve as well as no improvement after arthroscopy. If there is a clear cut meniscus tear, arthroscopy can be helpful. If there is generalized arthritis, i feel it is less likely to be helpful . Others may have a different opinion.

In brief: Possibly
There was a studydone in texas a few years ago that suggested that arthroscopy forknee problems was not more effective than placebo.
Having said that I have seen people improve as well as no improvement after arthroscopy. If there is a clear cut meniscus tear, arthroscopy can be helpful. If there is generalized arthritis, i feel it is less likely to be helpful . Others may have a different opinion.
Dr. Jay Rosenfeld
Dr. Jay Rosenfeld
Thank
Dr. Barry Waldman
Orthopedic Surgery - Reconstruction
In brief: Yes
If there is torn cartilage or mechanical symptoms, arthroscopy can sometimes be helpful.
Whether it is effective for general arthritic symptoms is controversial.

In brief: Yes
If there is torn cartilage or mechanical symptoms, arthroscopy can sometimes be helpful.
Whether it is effective for general arthritic symptoms is controversial.
Dr. Barry Waldman
Dr. Barry Waldman
Thank
Read more answers from doctors