3 doctors weighed in:

Which is the most effective: lap band, gastric bypass or gastric sleeve?

3 doctors weighed in
Dr. Gregg Nishi
Bariatrics
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Operations

In terms of ultimate weight loss, the bypass would be #1 followed closely by sleeve.
The band would be a distant third. For fixing problems like diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, sleep apnea, the ranking is the same. Sleeves are a good option for someone without diabetes or heartburn. If you have those problems or have a bmi over 50, the bypass is a better option.

In brief: Operations

In terms of ultimate weight loss, the bypass would be #1 followed closely by sleeve.
The band would be a distant third. For fixing problems like diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, sleep apnea, the ranking is the same. Sleeves are a good option for someone without diabetes or heartburn. If you have those problems or have a bmi over 50, the bypass is a better option.
Dr. Gregg Nishi
Dr. Gregg Nishi
Thank

In brief: You are

It isn't the surgery that is effective, it is the patient.
While the bypass will lose most weight in the first year, followed by the sleeve, then the band- it is an average. What counts most is how you use the tool - i've had patients lose all their weight in a year with all of these operations, and patients who have lost none. The key- change your eating habits, healthy food, small portions.

In brief: You are

It isn't the surgery that is effective, it is the patient.
While the bypass will lose most weight in the first year, followed by the sleeve, then the band- it is an average. What counts most is how you use the tool - i've had patients lose all their weight in a year with all of these operations, and patients who have lost none. The key- change your eating habits, healthy food, small portions.
Dr. Terry Simpson
Dr. Terry Simpson
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Mark Pack
Board Certified, Surgery
27 years in practice
3M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors