3 doctors weighed in:

Please explain the problem of checking vs. Non checking psa's?

3 doctors weighed in
Dr. James Lin
Urology

In brief: Here are some...

The connection of cancer to death has embedded in most people's mind.
To some kind of cancer, this may be true and relevant; to prostate cancer, it's not, but a different story. Meanwhile, the pros and cons of testing psa has undergone a fast pace of adjustment especially over the past 10 years.More detail on pros and cons on psa usage, go to http://formefirst.Com/newauapsa.Html

In brief: Here are some...

The connection of cancer to death has embedded in most people's mind.
To some kind of cancer, this may be true and relevant; to prostate cancer, it's not, but a different story. Meanwhile, the pros and cons of testing psa has undergone a fast pace of adjustment especially over the past 10 years.More detail on pros and cons on psa usage, go to http://formefirst.Com/newauapsa.Html
Dr. James Lin
Dr. James Lin
Thank
Dr. John Washburn
Family Medicine

In brief: Inconclusive

This question requires an extensive response, but the short answer is that psa has never been proven to save lives when used as a screening tool - that is, testing someone who is otherwise not having symptoms nor isn't considered to be at high risk for prostate cancer (no family history, etc).
In fact, using this test may even lead to unnecessary tests and medical procedures that aren't helpful.

In brief: Inconclusive

This question requires an extensive response, but the short answer is that psa has never been proven to save lives when used as a screening tool - that is, testing someone who is otherwise not having symptoms nor isn't considered to be at high risk for prostate cancer (no family history, etc).
In fact, using this test may even lead to unnecessary tests and medical procedures that aren't helpful.
Dr. John Washburn
Dr. John Washburn
Thank
Dr. Gurmukh Singh
Pathology

In brief: Not useful

Us preventive task force has determined that routine monitoring of healthy males with psa testing is not useful.

In brief: Not useful

Us preventive task force has determined that routine monitoring of healthy males with psa testing is not useful.
Dr. Gurmukh Singh
Dr. Gurmukh Singh
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Arnon Rubin
Board Certified,
20 years in practice
163K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors