10 doctors weighed in:
Removal of breast implants needed in all women?
10 doctors weighed in

Dr. Otto Placik
Surgery - Plastics
5 doctors agree
In brief: Not necessarily
With the current state of the art, implants may fail over your lifetime but that also means they may not.
If ruptured or if other complications develop, you will certainly want to remove/replace the implants when problems occur. However , in the absence of complications there is no need to remove them. In the future, fat transfer may offer a longer term solution.

In brief: Not necessarily
With the current state of the art, implants may fail over your lifetime but that also means they may not.
If ruptured or if other complications develop, you will certainly want to remove/replace the implants when problems occur. However , in the absence of complications there is no need to remove them. In the future, fat transfer may offer a longer term solution.
Dr. Otto Placik
Dr. Otto Placik
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Ramon Angel Robles
Fat graft transfer alone to the breasts will not offer a better long term solution for breast augmentation. When stem cells in the fat grafts can be converted with 100% certainty to new blood vessels, to make sure that all the fat grafted survives, then maybe implants will be replaced. Cost effective technology is not there yet.
Dr. Tom Pousti
Surgery - Plastics
1 doctor agrees
In brief: No.
No, breast implant removal is not necessary unless the breast implants are causing a specific problem, have leaked, and/or the patient chooses to have them removed.
On the other hand, patients who are planning on undergoing initial breast augmentation surgery should be aware that additional surgery related to their breast implants ( for a variety of reasons) may be necessary in their lifetimes.

In brief: No.
No, breast implant removal is not necessary unless the breast implants are causing a specific problem, have leaked, and/or the patient chooses to have them removed.
On the other hand, patients who are planning on undergoing initial breast augmentation surgery should be aware that additional surgery related to their breast implants ( for a variety of reasons) may be necessary in their lifetimes.
Dr. Tom Pousti
Dr. Tom Pousti
Thank
Dr. Alexander Nein
Surgery - Plastics
1 doctor agrees
In brief: No
Breast implants only "need" to be removed if there is something wrong with the integrity of the implant such as a leak in a silicone implant.
There is the option at that time of having it replaced or simply removed without replacement. Saline implants don't really "need" to be removed even if they leak, although the cosmetic result could be poor. Infected implants of any type need to be removed.

In brief: No
Breast implants only "need" to be removed if there is something wrong with the integrity of the implant such as a leak in a silicone implant.
There is the option at that time of having it replaced or simply removed without replacement. Saline implants don't really "need" to be removed even if they leak, although the cosmetic result could be poor. Infected implants of any type need to be removed.
Dr. Alexander Nein
Dr. Alexander Nein
Thank
Dr. Barry Press
Surgery - Plastics
1 doctor agrees
In brief: No
Breast implants only need to be removed if there is a problem: significant capsular contracture, leakage, deflation, or rarely, infection.
No problem, no removal necessary.

In brief: No
Breast implants only need to be removed if there is a problem: significant capsular contracture, leakage, deflation, or rarely, infection.
No problem, no removal necessary.
Dr. Barry Press
Dr. Barry Press
Thank
Dr. Barry Handler
Surgery - Plastics
In brief: Probably
Depending on how young you are when you put them in and how long you live it is best to plan that some time in the future the implants you have now will either need to be removed or replaced.
As imperfect as these devices are most women with failing implants choose to replace them if that is any indication of their popularity.

In brief: Probably
Depending on how young you are when you put them in and how long you live it is best to plan that some time in the future the implants you have now will either need to be removed or replaced.
As imperfect as these devices are most women with failing implants choose to replace them if that is any indication of their popularity.
Dr. Barry Handler
Dr. Barry Handler
Thank
Read more answers from doctors