53 doctors weighed in:

Can asthma be caused by smoking around the child or adult?

53 doctors weighed in
Dr. Yoram Padeh
Internal Medicine - Allergy & Immunology
18 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

Absolutely! the question asks about "second-hand" smoking, which can certainly cause asthma.
However, even "third-hand" smoking where the smoke toxins are carried in hair, clothing, skin, etc. Can cause asthma. That means even going outside for a smoke and coming back in without the cigarette can still put loved-ones at risk! smoking is a very selfish and inconsiderate act.

In brief: Yes

Absolutely! the question asks about "second-hand" smoking, which can certainly cause asthma.
However, even "third-hand" smoking where the smoke toxins are carried in hair, clothing, skin, etc. Can cause asthma. That means even going outside for a smoke and coming back in without the cigarette can still put loved-ones at risk! smoking is a very selfish and inconsiderate act.
Dr. Yoram Padeh
Dr. Yoram Padeh
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Gary Steven
Cotinine, a breakdown product of nicotine, has been found in the urine of children whose parents ONLY smoke outside the home. Any smoking, ANYWHERE, by any family members is bad for children, especially those with asthma.
Dr. Nisha Chellam
Internal Medicine
17 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

There have been studies that show kids born to smoking parents do indeed have a higher incidence of asthma and hypersensitive airway or lung disease.

In brief: Yes

There have been studies that show kids born to smoking parents do indeed have a higher incidence of asthma and hypersensitive airway or lung disease.
Dr. Nisha Chellam
Dr. Nisha Chellam
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Stanley Weiss
In other words, such exposure may contribute to developing asthma. In addiiton, for those who already have asthma, exposure to smoke can exacerbate it.
Dr. Bhavin Patel
Internal Medicine - Allergy & Immunology
8 doctors agree

In brief: Triggers asthma

Smoking and smoke exposure triggers asthma symptoms.
Also smoking when the childs airways are developing predisposes the child to develop reactive airways disease, which has symptoms and characteristics similar to asthma and treated the same as asthma.

In brief: Triggers asthma

Smoking and smoke exposure triggers asthma symptoms.
Also smoking when the childs airways are developing predisposes the child to develop reactive airways disease, which has symptoms and characteristics similar to asthma and treated the same as asthma.
Dr. Bhavin Patel
Dr. Bhavin Patel
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Stanley Weiss
"Reactive airways disease" is a flawed term, and is not a valid independent concept. Most persons labeled as having reactive airways disease are kids, and most of these have asthma of varying severity. The term mainly arose from some providers being fearful of the response and reactions families sometimes have to the term "asthma." Eduvcation is needed.
Dr. Steven Machtinger
Internal Medicine - Allergy & Immunology
7 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

The fetus is most vulnerable to smoking and many studies demonstrate that.
Children born to women who smoked during pregnancy have as high a rate of asthma as those born to non-smoking allergic mothers. Children & adults who already have asthma will have increased symptoms & exacerbations when in an environment with tobacco smoke.

In brief: Yes

The fetus is most vulnerable to smoking and many studies demonstrate that.
Children born to women who smoked during pregnancy have as high a rate of asthma as those born to non-smoking allergic mothers. Children & adults who already have asthma will have increased symptoms & exacerbations when in an environment with tobacco smoke.
Dr. Steven Machtinger
Dr. Steven Machtinger
Thank
Dr. Pierre Semrani
Family Medicine
5 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

This is sometime called "passive smoking" or "second hand exposure" where individuals with prolonged exposure to smoke inhalation, tend to later develop features of "smoker's lungs" which is somewhat a more severe form of asthma.
Think prevention!

In brief: Yes

This is sometime called "passive smoking" or "second hand exposure" where individuals with prolonged exposure to smoke inhalation, tend to later develop features of "smoker's lungs" which is somewhat a more severe form of asthma.
Think prevention!
Dr. Pierre Semrani
Dr. Pierre Semrani
Thank
Dr. Kevin Windisch
Pediatrics
4 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

Absolutely. Asthmatic need to avoid any and all tobacco smoke.

In brief: Yes

Absolutely. Asthmatic need to avoid any and all tobacco smoke.
Dr. Kevin Windisch
Dr. Kevin Windisch
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Susan Lurie
smoke is the most allergenic substance and should always be avoided around children or asthmatic adults.
Dr. Barry Bergman
Pediatrics
3 doctors agree

In brief: Caused?

The cause of asthma is mostly genetic but smoke will irritate and can trigger a wheezing episode in one with asthma.

In brief: Caused?

The cause of asthma is mostly genetic but smoke will irritate and can trigger a wheezing episode in one with asthma.
Dr. Barry Bergman
Dr. Barry Bergman
Thank
Dr. Mary Ann Block
General Practice
2 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

Absolutely! no one should smoke but there have been cases where smoking around a child with asthma has been considered child abuse.
Asthma is a potentially fatal disease and smoking around someone can increase that risk.

In brief: Yes

Absolutely! no one should smoke but there have been cases where smoking around a child with asthma has been considered child abuse.
Asthma is a potentially fatal disease and smoking around someone can increase that risk.
Dr. Mary Ann Block
Dr. Mary Ann Block
Thank
Dr. Kathleen Cullen
Internal Medicine
2 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

Asthma can be brought on by numerous factors including allergies, infections, stress, exposures such as smoke, exercise and certain drugs and foods.

In brief: Yes

Asthma can be brought on by numerous factors including allergies, infections, stress, exposures such as smoke, exercise and certain drugs and foods.
Dr. Kathleen Cullen
Dr. Kathleen Cullen
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Alan Khadavi
I agree.
Dr. Andrew Carroll
Family Medicine
2 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

Yes, there are several studies which have shown that children who live in households of smokers have a much higher rate of asthma as a result.
Children who live in those same homes also are more likely to get upper respiratory infections, ear infections, pneumonia, and many other illnesses.

In brief: Yes

Yes, there are several studies which have shown that children who live in households of smokers have a much higher rate of asthma as a result.
Children who live in those same homes also are more likely to get upper respiratory infections, ear infections, pneumonia, and many other illnesses.
Dr. Andrew Carroll
Dr. Andrew Carroll
Thank
Dr. Maziar Rezvani
Internal Medicine - Allergy & Immunology
1 doctor agrees

In brief: No

Asthma is not caused by environmental tobacco smoke.
Asthma is a chronic inflammatory lung condition that is characterized by reversible airway obstruction, which is an epigenetic phenomenon. Asthma symptoms include cough, chest tightness, wheezing and shortness of breath. Smoke is a common trigger for asthma symptoms in addition to colds, cold air, weather changes, pollens or exercise.

In brief: No

Asthma is not caused by environmental tobacco smoke.
Asthma is a chronic inflammatory lung condition that is characterized by reversible airway obstruction, which is an epigenetic phenomenon. Asthma symptoms include cough, chest tightness, wheezing and shortness of breath. Smoke is a common trigger for asthma symptoms in addition to colds, cold air, weather changes, pollens or exercise.
Dr. Maziar Rezvani
Dr. Maziar Rezvani
Thank
Dr. Mary Ann Block
General Practice
1 doctor agrees

In brief:

Studies have found that the smoke left on hair, skin and clothing even when smoking outside, can increase the dangers almost as much as smoking in the same room with someone with asthma.

In brief:

Studies have found that the smoke left on hair, skin and clothing even when smoking outside, can increase the dangers almost as much as smoking in the same room with someone with asthma.
Dr. Mary Ann Block
Dr. Mary Ann Block
Thank
Dr. Mary Ann Block
General Practice

In brief: Even smoking outside

Studies have found that even smoking outside can increase asthma risk.
The smoke on the clothes, hair and skin when retiring to the inside of the house has been found to be almost as dangerous as smoking inside.

In brief: Even smoking outside

Studies have found that even smoking outside can increase asthma risk.
The smoke on the clothes, hair and skin when retiring to the inside of the house has been found to be almost as dangerous as smoking inside.
Dr. Mary Ann Block
Dr. Mary Ann Block
Thank
Dr. Jason Campbell
Family Medicine

In brief: Yes

Smoke - either cigarette or even wood-burning - is considered a respiratory irritant.
As such, smoke can cause an inflammatory or respiratory spasm response producing asthma symptoms in any individual - regardless of age.

In brief: Yes

Smoke - either cigarette or even wood-burning - is considered a respiratory irritant.
As such, smoke can cause an inflammatory or respiratory spasm response producing asthma symptoms in any individual - regardless of age.
Dr. Jason Campbell
Dr. Jason Campbell
Thank
Dr. Paige Gutheil
Family Medicine

In brief: Yes

Asthma symptoms can be brought out by smoking or smoke exposure.
There are many other factors, including a genetic tendency towards asthma involved as well.

In brief: Yes

Asthma symptoms can be brought out by smoking or smoke exposure.
There are many other factors, including a genetic tendency towards asthma involved as well.
Dr. Paige Gutheil
Dr. Paige Gutheil
Thank
Dr. Theodore Cole
Family Medicine

In brief: Yes

Smoke is a toxin, and can cause irritation, tissue damage, and sensitivity (allergy) over time.
People of all ages have increased rates of asthma and many other illnesses when exposed to second-hand smoke.

In brief: Yes

Smoke is a toxin, and can cause irritation, tissue damage, and sensitivity (allergy) over time.
People of all ages have increased rates of asthma and many other illnesses when exposed to second-hand smoke.
Dr. Theodore Cole
Dr. Theodore Cole
Thank
Dr. Dean Giannone
Internal Medicine

In brief: No

Given that asthma is intrinsic to the individual, you can't cause asthma by smoking around a child.
However, asthmatic children in houses with smokers experience more symptoms and hospitalizations related to asthma.

In brief: No

Given that asthma is intrinsic to the individual, you can't cause asthma by smoking around a child.
However, asthmatic children in houses with smokers experience more symptoms and hospitalizations related to asthma.
Dr. Dean Giannone
Dr. Dean Giannone
Thank
Read more answers from doctors