5 doctors weighed in:

Should 58 year old woman with family history of osteoporosis take 2 citrical plus d/ day given findings about calcium and heart attack ?

5 doctors weighed in
Dr. Bac Nguyen
Family Medicine
2 doctors agree

In brief: How is her diet?

U r absolutely right about the new controversy regarding calcium supplements and cardiac risk, but it does not say anything about calcium in diet/foods.
So, consuming calcium rich foods will reduce need to take supplement. Also, vitamin use can improve absorption of calcium. But, she should check with her doc for a possible scan to how her done is at this time, then treatment. Good luck.

In brief: How is her diet?

U r absolutely right about the new controversy regarding calcium supplements and cardiac risk, but it does not say anything about calcium in diet/foods.
So, consuming calcium rich foods will reduce need to take supplement. Also, vitamin use can improve absorption of calcium. But, she should check with her doc for a possible scan to how her done is at this time, then treatment. Good luck.
Dr. Bac Nguyen
Dr. Bac Nguyen
Thank
Dr. Terri Washington
Internal Medicine - Endocrinology
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Discuss with Dr

D/w your doctor the risk and benefits.
You are right about risk of heart disease which has been shown in several studies recently. Thought is it may be better to get calcium through the diet with 3 serving of dairy +/- 8oz glass of oj with calcium daily.

In brief: Discuss with Dr

D/w your doctor the risk and benefits.
You are right about risk of heart disease which has been shown in several studies recently. Thought is it may be better to get calcium through the diet with 3 serving of dairy +/- 8oz glass of oj with calcium daily.
Dr. Terri Washington
Dr. Terri Washington
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Adam Smith
Board Certified, Internal Medicine
14 years in practice
382K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors