4 doctors weighed in:

Torn lateral meniscus, should I have meniscectomy or meniscus repair?

4 doctors weighed in
Dr. Kenneth Tepper
Orthopedic Surgery
2 doctors agree

In brief: Depends

If a repair is possible, that would typically be best.
The meniscus is a shock absorber inside the knee, and with removal or meniscectomy, there is greater risk for arthritis. Every tear however cannot be repaired, and the tear pattern, location of tear, quality of tissue, and expectations of the patient need to be considered. There will be restrictions after surgery if the meniscus is repaired.

In brief: Depends

If a repair is possible, that would typically be best.
The meniscus is a shock absorber inside the knee, and with removal or meniscectomy, there is greater risk for arthritis. Every tear however cannot be repaired, and the tear pattern, location of tear, quality of tissue, and expectations of the patient need to be considered. There will be restrictions after surgery if the meniscus is repaired.
Dr. Kenneth Tepper
Dr. Kenneth Tepper
Thank
Dr. Darren Corteen
Orthopedic Surgery
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Depends

In young person (less than 40) meniscal repair preferred if possible.
It has important function helping to distribute load in knee and protect cartilage over ends of bone. However depends entirely on character of tear as some tears simply not repairable. Blood supply of meniscus also somewhat precarious and therefore tearing in some areas has low probablity of healing.

In brief: Depends

In young person (less than 40) meniscal repair preferred if possible.
It has important function helping to distribute load in knee and protect cartilage over ends of bone. However depends entirely on character of tear as some tears simply not repairable. Blood supply of meniscus also somewhat precarious and therefore tearing in some areas has low probablity of healing.
Dr. Darren Corteen
Dr. Darren Corteen
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Warren Strudwick
Board Certified, Sports Medicine
28 years in practice
491K people helped
Continue
111,000 doctors available