10 doctors weighed in:
I have an anterior osteophytic ridge that pushed against my esophagus, effacing the mid and right lateral lumen. An ENT recommended surgery. Should i?
10 doctors weighed in

Dr. David Astrachan
ENT - Head & Neck Surgery
6 doctors agree
In brief: Maybe
In my 23 years of practice I have operated on two people with osteophytes so large that it impaired their swallowing.
I have probably seen hundreds of x-rays showing enlarged osteophytes causing an impression upon the esophagus in patients with swallowing difficulty. In almost all cases we were able to come up with other treatments to help their swallowing. I strongly recommend a second opinion.

In brief: Maybe
In my 23 years of practice I have operated on two people with osteophytes so large that it impaired their swallowing.
I have probably seen hundreds of x-rays showing enlarged osteophytes causing an impression upon the esophagus in patients with swallowing difficulty. In almost all cases we were able to come up with other treatments to help their swallowing. I strongly recommend a second opinion.
Dr. David Astrachan
Dr. David Astrachan
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Patrick Melder
totally agree with Dr. Astrachan. I can't recall a time I have operated on one... but you may.. so keep that in mind... during a second opinon.
Dr. Andrew Turrisi
Radiation Oncology
2 doctors agree
In brief: Sounds like you are
Uncomfortable. Ask the doc what the approach is and potential side effects, how common is the surgery.
If you live in a city with more than one, get a second opinion. It somes down to how bothersome the problem is to you and the potential benefit versus risk of complication and even death. Choose after being fully informed. Good luck.

In brief: Sounds like you are
Uncomfortable. Ask the doc what the approach is and potential side effects, how common is the surgery.
If you live in a city with more than one, get a second opinion. It somes down to how bothersome the problem is to you and the potential benefit versus risk of complication and even death. Choose after being fully informed. Good luck.
Dr. Andrew Turrisi
Dr. Andrew Turrisi
Thank
Dr. Abe Dumanis
Dentistry
In brief: Yes
Whatever ENT recommends.

In brief: Yes
Whatever ENT recommends.
Dr. Abe Dumanis
Dr. Abe Dumanis
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Crystal Twynham
Board Certified, Surgery
29 years in practice
938K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors