8 doctors weighed in:

Is diet coke better than sugared sodas, if soda is given to children?

8 doctors weighed in
2 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

It is better to avoid soda altogether. But diet soda would be preferred.

In brief: Yes

It is better to avoid soda altogether. But diet soda would be preferred.
Dr. Anthony LaBarbera
Dr. Anthony LaBarbera
Thank
Dr. Andres R Villar
Pediatrics
1 doctor agrees

In brief: Diet soda???

Corn syrup or asparmate? Pick your poison.
The fda has ruled that the sweetener in diet drinks asparmate is safe for consumption at current doses in drinks...Uhmmm asparmate breaks dwon into methanol under extreme acidic or alkalinic conditions.Don't believe the fear mongering in the internet, but as long as there is water, milk and natural fruit juices, the choice is pretty clear.

In brief: Diet soda???

Corn syrup or asparmate? Pick your poison.
The fda has ruled that the sweetener in diet drinks asparmate is safe for consumption at current doses in drinks...Uhmmm asparmate breaks dwon into methanol under extreme acidic or alkalinic conditions.Don't believe the fear mongering in the internet, but as long as there is water, milk and natural fruit juices, the choice is pretty clear.
Dr. Andres R Villar
Dr. Andres R Villar
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Carlos Encarnacion
And once hooked to it, good luck getting out. Believe me, I know..... Do not give your kids that stuff.
Dr. James Ferguson
Pediatrics

In brief: Neither are good

Unfortunately, the quest to give us a sweetness fix without calories may actually be worse than natural sugar.
If you want to program your baby's brain to crave sweets, and then battle that craving for life, offer it often in any form.That may be why so many kids now face obesity even before school age. I favor never using food or sweats as a reward. You may regret the long term effect.

In brief: Neither are good

Unfortunately, the quest to give us a sweetness fix without calories may actually be worse than natural sugar.
If you want to program your baby's brain to crave sweets, and then battle that craving for life, offer it often in any form.That may be why so many kids now face obesity even before school age. I favor never using food or sweats as a reward. You may regret the long term effect.
Dr. James Ferguson
Dr. James Ferguson
Thank
Dr. Richard Levenson
Clinical Psychology

In brief: Both not too good

Diet coke has aspartame, coke has sugar.
Neither are good for children's diets. Stick to milk, water, and juices if you can.

In brief: Both not too good

Diet coke has aspartame, coke has sugar.
Neither are good for children's diets. Stick to milk, water, and juices if you can.
Dr. Richard Levenson
Dr. Richard Levenson
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Shontae Buffington
Board Certified, Pediatrics
13 years in practice
838K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors