16 doctors weighed in:

Are people with dementia still wise?

16 doctors weighed in
Dr. Eloise Potenza
Clinical Psychology
9 doctors agree

In brief: Yes

Yes they are still wise in many areas.
Memory loss and confusion typically start with difficulty in forming new memories and gradually progress into other areas. Factual knowledge is retrieved in a different manner that personal memories. The degree of dementia determines which areas are most profoundly affected so a person can be wise but unable to identify familiar individuals.

In brief: Yes

Yes they are still wise in many areas.
Memory loss and confusion typically start with difficulty in forming new memories and gradually progress into other areas. Factual knowledge is retrieved in a different manner that personal memories. The degree of dementia determines which areas are most profoundly affected so a person can be wise but unable to identify familiar individuals.
Dr. Eloise Potenza
Dr. Eloise Potenza
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Nicholas Nomicos
A very perceptive question and excellent answer.
Dr. Kalyn Diamond
Clinical Psychology
5 doctors agree

In brief: It Depends

Being wise refers to an ability to discern or judge what is true or right, and implies common sense and good judgment.
While some likely are wise, and are able to discern or judge what is true or right, and have good common sense and judgment, others may no longer exhibit this quality. The presence or absence of “being wise” may vary on the type and severity of the dementia, and on other factors.

In brief: It Depends

Being wise refers to an ability to discern or judge what is true or right, and implies common sense and good judgment.
While some likely are wise, and are able to discern or judge what is true or right, and have good common sense and judgment, others may no longer exhibit this quality. The presence or absence of “being wise” may vary on the type and severity of the dementia, and on other factors.
Dr. Kalyn Diamond
Dr. Kalyn Diamond
Thank
Dr. Susan Uhrich
Psychiatry
3 doctors agree

In brief: Memory loss

Is not an all or nothing thing, so yes, some dementia patients are wise, particularly early in the illness.

In brief: Memory loss

Is not an all or nothing thing, so yes, some dementia patients are wise, particularly early in the illness.
Dr. Susan Uhrich
Dr. Susan Uhrich
Thank
Dr. Dheeraj Raina
Psychiatry
2 doctors agree

In brief: Maybe

They may still be wise though they may be unable to communicate their wisdom.

In brief: Maybe

They may still be wise though they may be unable to communicate their wisdom.
Dr. Dheeraj Raina
Dr. Dheeraj Raina
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Eric Weisman
Board Certified, Neurology
32 years in practice
9M people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors