11 doctors weighed in:

Is a medial mensicu displacement considered a bucket tear? Is the mcmurray test the only test that they give?

11 doctors weighed in
Dr. Ahmad M Hadied
Orthopedic Surgery
7 doctors agree

In brief: NO

According to some sources, the sensitivity of the mcmurray test for medial meniscus tears is 53% and the specificity is 59%.
The best test know is the mri.The show the buckett handle tear which defer than medial displacement.

In brief: NO

According to some sources, the sensitivity of the mcmurray test for medial meniscus tears is 53% and the specificity is 59%.
The best test know is the mri.The show the buckett handle tear which defer than medial displacement.
Dr. Ahmad M Hadied
Dr. Ahmad M Hadied
Thank
Dr. Peter Nefcy
Radiology

In brief: Maybe

A bucket handle tear means that a strip of meniscal cartilage, usually still attached at the front and back, is displaced and can move back and forth like moving a bucket handle.
Displace cartilage can be a bucket handle, a flap if attached at one end, or a free fragment. Parts of the cartilage can also be displaced out of the joint in patients with joint narrowing. The best study is an MRI.

In brief: Maybe

A bucket handle tear means that a strip of meniscal cartilage, usually still attached at the front and back, is displaced and can move back and forth like moving a bucket handle.
Displace cartilage can be a bucket handle, a flap if attached at one end, or a free fragment. Parts of the cartilage can also be displaced out of the joint in patients with joint narrowing. The best study is an MRI.
Dr. Peter Nefcy
Dr. Peter Nefcy
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Peter Ihle
Displaced meniscus usually mean Ur knee will lock & not B able to B extended, if medial. Buckets may not B able 2 B reduced. Displaced tears can B reduced @ times by wiggling the knee (so called trick knee).
Dr. Mark Weston
Orthopedic Surgery - Spine

In brief: Appply grind, mri

Adiagnostic arthroscopy other teatmri goold standard test arthrogram oldee test.

In brief: Appply grind, mri

Adiagnostic arthroscopy other teatmri goold standard test arthrogram oldee test.
Dr. Mark Weston
Dr. Mark Weston
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Warren Strudwick
Board Certified, Sports Medicine
26 years in practice
491K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors