9 doctors weighed in:
If major surgeries have been done and wall hernia is found then which is better laproscopic or open surgery?
9 doctors weighed in

Dr. Miguel Cano
Obstetrics & Gynecology
4 doctors agree
In brief: Depends
Usually this depends on the size of the hernia, the amount of adhesions, and the type of repair needed (prior mesh? Need more? Prior failed repairs?).
All of these questions need to be addressed by your surgeon prior to surgery. If it can be done laparoscopically that would be an easier recovery for you, but again, ask your surgeon.

In brief: Depends
Usually this depends on the size of the hernia, the amount of adhesions, and the type of repair needed (prior mesh? Need more? Prior failed repairs?).
All of these questions need to be addressed by your surgeon prior to surgery. If it can be done laparoscopically that would be an easier recovery for you, but again, ask your surgeon.
Dr. Miguel Cano
Dr. Miguel Cano
Thank
3 doctors agree
In brief: Depends
If you simply want mesh screen placed over the defect to prevent bowel or other abdominal contents from entering, laparoscopic incisional herniorrhaphy is a good choice.
If your hernia is large and especially if you want abdominal wall integrity restored, this frequently requires abdominal wall reconstruction using open surgical techniques like components separation. Discuss with your surgeon.

In brief: Depends
If you simply want mesh screen placed over the defect to prevent bowel or other abdominal contents from entering, laparoscopic incisional herniorrhaphy is a good choice.
If your hernia is large and especially if you want abdominal wall integrity restored, this frequently requires abdominal wall reconstruction using open surgical techniques like components separation. Discuss with your surgeon.
Dr. Michael Sawyer
Dr. Michael Sawyer
Thank
Dr. David Earle
Surgery
In brief: Depends on goals
It depends on what you want to get out of the repair. Is it for a specific problem like a large deformity, pain, or both? Skin ulceration, difficulty placing an ostomy appliance and limitations of activities are also reasons to repair a hernia.
Repair for prevention is also reasonable. Pick a technique that can most likely meet your goals. An experienced hernia surgeon has lots of options.

In brief: Depends on goals
It depends on what you want to get out of the repair. Is it for a specific problem like a large deformity, pain, or both? Skin ulceration, difficulty placing an ostomy appliance and limitations of activities are also reasons to repair a hernia.
Repair for prevention is also reasonable. Pick a technique that can most likely meet your goals. An experienced hernia surgeon has lots of options.
Dr. David Earle
Dr. David Earle
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Buck Parker
Board Certified, Surgery
13 years in practice
467K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors