25 doctors weighed in:
Why should I see a plastic surgeon or mohs surgeon instead of derm doctor for skin cancer removal and repair?
25 doctors weighed in

Dr. Joseph Duvall
Dermatology
8 doctors agree
In brief: Location
Skin cancers in difficult places(eyes, nose, ears) should always be removed by mohs surgery.
It is the only procedure that will assure you have had your skin cancer removed completely. Mohs surgeons are excellent at repairing defects and if they are not confident in their skill they will let a plastic surgeon repair the defect.

In brief: Location
Skin cancers in difficult places(eyes, nose, ears) should always be removed by mohs surgery.
It is the only procedure that will assure you have had your skin cancer removed completely. Mohs surgeons are excellent at repairing defects and if they are not confident in their skill they will let a plastic surgeon repair the defect.
Dr. Joseph Duvall
Dr. Joseph Duvall
Thank
Dr. Antonio Cruz
Dermatology
4 doctors agree
In brief: Depends..
I think it depends on the location and type of skin cancer.
Most dermatologists are comfortable performing simple excisions or may refer to plastics or a dermatological surgeon. Most skin cancers on the face are removed via mohs surgery, the reconstruction is either performed by the mohs surgeon or coordinated with a plastic surgeon/ent or oculoplastics. www.mohspros.com.

In brief: Depends..
I think it depends on the location and type of skin cancer.
Most dermatologists are comfortable performing simple excisions or may refer to plastics or a dermatological surgeon. Most skin cancers on the face are removed via mohs surgery, the reconstruction is either performed by the mohs surgeon or coordinated with a plastic surgeon/ent or oculoplastics. www.mohspros.com.
Dr. Antonio Cruz
Dr. Antonio Cruz
Thank
Dr. Ally-Khan Somani
Dermatology
3 doctors agree
In brief: Training
The acms fellowship (www.
Skincancermohssurgery.Org) established by dr. F. Mohs is acknowledged as the benchmark in mohs surgery training. Through an extensive application and interview process, only the most qualified physicians are selected by acms to participate in a fellowship program. Participants must undergo a rigorous 1-2 yr training program after completing a residency in dermatology.

In brief: Training
The acms fellowship (www.
Skincancermohssurgery.Org) established by dr. F. Mohs is acknowledged as the benchmark in mohs surgery training. Through an extensive application and interview process, only the most qualified physicians are selected by acms to participate in a fellowship program. Participants must undergo a rigorous 1-2 yr training program after completing a residency in dermatology.
Dr. Ally-Khan Somani
Dr. Ally-Khan Somani
Thank
Dr. Gene Wong
Radiation Oncology
3 doctors agree
In brief: Specialized training
Generally speaking, dermatologist can diagnose and treat skin cancer.
However, one needs special training to to moh's surgery and that's why some patients are referred to specialist for this procedure. The procedure is like peeling off onion skin layer by layer until the skin is cancer free.

In brief: Specialized training
Generally speaking, dermatologist can diagnose and treat skin cancer.
However, one needs special training to to moh's surgery and that's why some patients are referred to specialist for this procedure. The procedure is like peeling off onion skin layer by layer until the skin is cancer free.
Dr. Gene Wong
Dr. Gene Wong
Thank
Dr. Arlo Miller
Dermatology
2 doctors agree
In brief: Mohs
Dermatologic surgeons perform far more skin cancer removals than any other specialty.
For most skin cancers, you will benefit most from their experience. In the rare instance that the tumor is very large (> 1 or 2 cm) or in very challenging anatomic locations (for isntance feet, genitals, eyelids) referral to another surgeon or a team approach will be better.

In brief: Mohs
Dermatologic surgeons perform far more skin cancer removals than any other specialty.
For most skin cancers, you will benefit most from their experience. In the rare instance that the tumor is very large (> 1 or 2 cm) or in very challenging anatomic locations (for isntance feet, genitals, eyelids) referral to another surgeon or a team approach will be better.
Dr. Arlo Miller
Dr. Arlo Miller
Thank
2 comments
Dr. John Rimmer
MOHs surgery is recommended for removing skin cancers in locations eg the face where every mm of skin is important other locations less so
2 doctors agree
In brief: Either
Both plastic surgeons and dermatological surgeons will treat skin cancers .
For large tumors that require extensive resection and reconstruction plastic surgeons are needed.

In brief: Either
Both plastic surgeons and dermatological surgeons will treat skin cancers .
For large tumors that require extensive resection and reconstruction plastic surgeons are needed.
Dr. Addagada Rao
Dr. Addagada Rao
Thank
1 comment
Dr. Donald Shenenberger
Mohs and Plastic surgeons are equally capable of treating skin cancer on cosmetically sensitive areas (among other Mohs indications). If you have concerns that you may not need this type of surgeon then I suggest you ask the referring physician his or her reasoning.
Dr. M. Christine Lee
Dermatology
1 doctor agrees
In brief: Mohs highest cure
Mohs is the gold standard for treating skin cancer (highest cure rate).
Need to verify that your mohs surgeon is recognized as a fellowship-trained surgeon. Only members of the american college of mohs surgery (acms) are fellowship trained to perform mohs surgery. All members and fellows of the acms are listed on their website directory. The link to the acms website: http://www.Mohscollege.Org/.

In brief: Mohs highest cure
Mohs is the gold standard for treating skin cancer (highest cure rate).
Need to verify that your mohs surgeon is recognized as a fellowship-trained surgeon. Only members of the american college of mohs surgery (acms) are fellowship trained to perform mohs surgery. All members and fellows of the acms are listed on their website directory. The link to the acms website: http://www.Mohscollege.Org/.
Dr. M. Christine Lee
Dr. M. Christine Lee
Thank
1 comment
Dr. David Earle
Be careful with melanoma. May need a wider excision, but some MOH's surgeons with significant experience may be ok.
Dr. Ally-Khan Somani
Dermatology
In brief: Great question!
First thing you want to do is to have the tumor completely removed.
The way to ensure this is to have mohs micrographic surgery (www.Skincancermohssurgery.Org). Mohs surgery is skin sparing surgery with the highest cure rate (99%). The surgeon will check all the surgical margins to ensure that all the roots have been removed & then will repair the defect in a way which minimizes scar the same day.

In brief: Great question!
First thing you want to do is to have the tumor completely removed.
The way to ensure this is to have mohs micrographic surgery (www.Skincancermohssurgery.Org). Mohs surgery is skin sparing surgery with the highest cure rate (99%). The surgeon will check all the surgical margins to ensure that all the roots have been removed & then will repair the defect in a way which minimizes scar the same day.
Dr. Ally-Khan Somani
Dr. Ally-Khan Somani
Thank
In brief: Plastic
Mohs surgery is done by dermatologist however simple excision by a plastic surgeon is often faster with a better result.

In brief: Plastic
Mohs surgery is done by dermatologist however simple excision by a plastic surgeon is often faster with a better result.
Dr. Terry Simpson
Dr. Terry Simpson
Thank
Get help from a real doctor now
Dr. Buck Parker
Board Certified, Surgery
13 years in practice
467K people helped
Continue
108,000 doctors available
Read more answers from doctors