Top
30
Doctor insights on: Meniscus Surgery Repair Vs Removal

Share
1

1
About to have 2nd torn meniscus surgery... Is a repair or removal better and why does this keep happening. Only 24 and never had accident or injury?

About to have 2nd torn meniscus surgery... Is a repair or removal better and why does this keep happening. Only 24 and never had accident or injury?

Repair if possible: Only certain types of tears (peripheral around the rim) are repairable. Results are somewhat age dependent younger better than older people have better results. Partial meniscectomy still has a chance of increased arthritis in the long run. Joe dimaggio ripped his meniscus standing up on a bus so there doesn't have to be result of an accident. ...Read more

2

2
What is involved with meniscus removal arthroscopy surgery?

What is involved with meniscus removal arthroscopy surgery?

See below: It depends on what it done.

A meniscal repair takes a 5week-6week non wt bearing and brace time.

Simple triming of a tear takes only as long as the skin wounds heal. The internal mechanics of the knee are ready to go right away, as the mechanical problem has been removed. ...Read more

3

3
Meniscus removal surgery for knee problems? How successful is it?

Meniscus removal surgery for knee problems? How successful is it?

It depends: If your pain is from a meniscus tear then surgery by a skilled orthopedist is usually very successful. Most people are significantly improved in weeks. ...Read more

4

4
Should my knee be sore after playing football after meniscus removal surgery?

Sore knee: Some soreness is not uncommon, but soreness that does not resolve with ice, rest and anti-inflammatory medicines needs to be evaluated. ...Read more

5

5
Day after partial meniscus removal surgery. Almost blacked out after getting up to go to the restroom. Taking Vicodin. Did I get up too fast?

Day after partial meniscus removal surgery. Almost blacked out after getting up to go to the restroom. Taking Vicodin. Did I get up too fast?

Drink more fluids!: Orthostatic hypotension (decrease in blood pressure) is likely the cause. Do try and rise to stand slower initially, but definitely drink more fluids, do your calf pumps, ice, and elevate. ...Read more

7

7
I have opposite knee pain after having meniscus removal and patella surgery in other knee. Why?

I have opposite knee pain after having meniscus removal and patella surgery in other knee. Why?

Common: Surgery on one knee can cause a change in leg length changing your gait or can simply alter gait by changing knee function. The 'good' knee often takes the brunt of these changes & starts to hurt. A good physician might be able to determine the exact dysfunction (ex. Short leg syndrome;nerve inflammation) & provide a heel lift, osteopathic manipulation, neuroprolotherapy or other recommendation ...Read more

8

8
Opposite knee pain after having meniscus removal and patella surgery in other knee, what to do?

Opposite knee pain after having meniscus removal and patella surgery in other knee, what to do?

See Surgeon: Because your gait has changed the stresses on your other knee have also changed. Talk to your Orthopedic Surgeon. Physical Therapy may be in order. ...Read more

10

10
Do minor meniscus tears require surgery or can it repair itself?

Do minor meniscus tears require surgery or can it repair itself?

NO BLOOD SUPPLY: You can live with the symptoms if you are low acdtivity person; otherwise you need surgery. ...Read more

11

11
5 years ago I tore my meniscus and had surgery to repair. If I bend it too far it pops as is very painful. Is this normal?

5 years ago I tore my meniscus and had surgery to repair. If I bend it too far it pops as is very painful. Is this normal?

No: With that history, one would be concerned that you never actually healed or that you had another tear in the meniscus in question. Let you surgeon know. Consider an mri. Thankyou. ...Read more

12

12
What is the recovery time from meniscus repair surgery?

3-4 months: If you had a true repair and plan to return to sports then to be safe it's best to wait 3-4 months for full recovery. ...Read more

13

13
How long can I wait before doing meniscus repair surgery?

How long can I wait before doing meniscus repair surgery?

No definite answer: Meniscus tears that are repairable should be repaired as expeditiously as possible. No one can know for certain when or if another injury will occur. Further injury may convert a repairable tear to a tear that cannot be repaired but only partially removed. While waiting for a likely repair, it is prudent to greatly limit any activities that put the knee and meniscus at risk for further injury. ...Read more

14

14
How long does it take to recover after meniscus repair surgery?

Depends: Depends on the extent of the injury and the type of repair_ open vs arthroscopic can have a different recovery time of weeks. What type of surgery are you having? Is the meniscus completely torn, partially torn, ? ...Read more

15

15
How long does it typically take to recover from meniscus repair surgery?

How long does it typically take to recover from meniscus repair surgery?

Crutches for 6 weeks: Most meniscal repair surgeries, whether done open or arthroscopically, require up to 6 weeks of limited weight bearing with crutches. Most surgeons allow at least the weight of the foot to touch the ground during that time. Physical therapy is geared at working on quadriceps function/strength and limited knee motion from 0-90 degrees. Bracing in extension for ambulation may be indicated as well. ...Read more

16

16
Please tell me how long it takes for to recover from meniscus repair surgery?

Please tell me how long it takes for to recover from meniscus repair surgery?

Generally upto 6 mon: Ths, but your surgeon should be advising you as a lot depends on how the surgery went and the state of your tissues and the repair. So heed you surgeons advice as it might be less or even more. ...Read more

17

17
Hi, I have a torn meniscus for last 4 years. I want to repair it naturally. .. Without surgery. .. I feel pain all the time. .

No: It is very rare for a meniscus to heal without intervention. It really depends on where the tear is. If it is peripheral, it can be sewn together if at the time of surgery it looks like an appropriate option. These choices really are made in surgery. Some will advocate injecting prp into the tear but there is mixed information on this. If you have had this for 4 years, I doubt it will ever heal. ...Read more

19

19
I just had meniscus repair surgery, how long before I can walk?

I just had meniscus repair surgery, how long before I can walk?

Meniscus repair: It depends on the severity, size, and location of the tear. The safest taking is to stay on crutches and discuss plan with your doctor. ...Read more

20

20
I just had meniscus repair surgery how long until I can walk on it?

I just had meniscus repair surgery how long until I can walk on it?

After few days: Patients are given crutches, and instructed to walk with the crutches. Most often, patients will be allowed to place weight on the operated leg so long as the knee is held fully straight (either with a knee immobilizer or a hinged knee brace locked in extension). ...Read more

21

21
Are there any side effects from surgery to repair a torn meniscus?

No realy: Repair of the meniscus help the joint stay healthy avoid arthritis in the future. The only side effect the side effects from the procedure itself, all surgeries have potential complications. ...Read more

22

22
I just had meniscus repair surgery. How long am waiting until I can walk safely on it?

It depends: Depending on the type of repair, your surgeon may protect your weightbearing and your activities to maximize healing. If part of the torn meniscus was removed, you would be allowed to walk as soon as you feel able. However, if the torn meniscus was repaired with sutures, then you might need to use crutches (partial weightbearing) for 4-6 weeks and gradually resume walking. Check with the doc. ...Read more

24

24
I just got my meniscus repaired a month ago. It has just started popping and now its swelling. Is this normal after meniscus surgery?

I just got my meniscus repaired a month ago. It has just started popping and now its swelling. Is this normal after meniscus surgery?

No;see your ortho MD: The clicking and popping sounds should be gone, and there should be minimal swelling at one month out. In particular, you should not have NEW swelling. You have risk for an infection. Follow up with your surgeon ASAP. ...Read more

25

25
Had surgery to repair discoid meniscus a month ago. Should it still hurt so much that I can barely walk? It feels the same as before surgery.

Had surgery to repair discoid meniscus a month ago. Should it still hurt so much that I can barely walk? It feels the same as before surgery.

Discoid Meniscus: The discoid meniscus and lateral meniscal surgery often take longer to heal. More important is what else was seen at surgery. If cartilage damage or arthritis - then the source of pain may have been that. You say "repair" but often what is really done is "resect" or remove the discoid meniscus. A failed "repair" (sewing together) could cause same kind of pain. ...Read more

26

26
I'm 20yrs old guy, after meniscus repair surgery & rehab. After 1 year can I be back to my high intensity exercises or should I stop them permanently?

I'm 20yrs old guy, after meniscus repair surgery & rehab. After 1 year can I be back to my high intensity exercises or should I stop them permanently?

Ask your ortho: I would think you should gradually work your way up. I am not sure how you obtained the tear but don't damage your outcome.
Ask your ortho doctor how best to recover and if you have any limitations. All the best. ...Read more

27

27
How much pain is there after acl/meniscus repair surgery?

How much pain is there after acl/meniscus repair surgery?

Variable: That depends on a number of factors: 1) allograft or autograft - when using your own tendon (either patellar tendon or hamstring tendon), the donor site (where we get the tendon) typically hurts more than the acl reconstruction. 2) type of acl reconstruction - some surgeons are performing "all-inside" acl reconstructions that have significantly less surgical pain, 3) individual pain tolerance. ...Read more

28

28
Is it normal that a year after arthroscopic surgery to repair a meniscus I still have major pain?

Is it normal that a year after arthroscopic surgery to repair a meniscus I still have major pain?

Not usually: The pain after a meniscus repair usually resolves within 6 weeks. If the pain is persistent, a further workup may be necessary. Perhaps even a repeat mri. ...Read more

29

29
Now that the MRI picked up a meniscus root displacement on a MRI after surgery does that ean I need surgery again to repair the displacement?

Now that the MRI picked up a meniscus root displacement on a MRI after surgery does that ean I need surgery again to repair the displacement?

See below: I am not an orthopedic surgeon but my understanding is that meniscal root repair is not simple. It's not like the simple debridement of some other types of meniscal tear. That being said meniscal root tear is significant, causing an unstable meniscus, particularly if it's the medial meniscus. Surgery, however, depends not only on MRI but also your symptoms and expectations. ...Read more