Top
40
Doctor insights on: Magnesium Glycinate Vs Malate

Share
2

2
Is magnesium gluconte and mgnesium glycinate the same?

Is magnesium gluconte and mgnesium glycinate the same?

No: Magnesium glycinate is the chelated form of magnesium that tends to provide the highest levels of mg and is good for correcting mg deficiency. Magnesium gluconate is the mg salt of gluconic acid. Gluconic acid occurs naturally in fruit, honey, and wines. ...Read more

3

3
Magnesium glycinate vs citrate which is more effective?

Depends: Both are a good source of elementary magnesium supplement in deficiency. Magnesium cittrate is a laxative and good for constipation but citrate inscreases stomach acid assimilation and worsen pain especailly people with acid reflux or if taken in empty stomach. The glycine in magnesium glycinate is an Amino Acid can help with sleep and feeling calm if taken at night. It is not a laxative. ...Read more

6

6
Can I take D3 and magnesium glycinate together?

Yes: You bet. One of the common mistakes with taking extra Vitamin D3 is not taking enough. Magnesium. The only time you need to be cautious is if you suffer from kidney disease and have renal insufficiency. ...Read more

7

7
Is magnesium glycinate the same as magnesium bis-glysinate?

Is magnesium glycinate the same as magnesium bis-glysinate?

I think so: Interesting question. I spent quite a bit of time researching this and have not found a definitive answer, but as far as I could tell they are different names for the same thing. If any doctors here have other information I hope they will share it.
I find magnesium glycinate/bis-glycinate and magnesium taurate to the best-absorbed and best-tolerated form of oral magnesium. ...Read more

8

8
I'm a woman 29 years old and I would like to know if taking daily 400mg of magnesium glycinate is ok. I can't find 250mg anywhere. Thanks?

Yes: Your average daily intake should be about 310 mg of Magnesium and this number goes up when you're pregnant. But to answer your question 400 mg a day should be fine. ...Read more

9

9
Is it safe to take 400mg magnesium glycinate daily? Do I need to worry about toxic levels from this dose?

Absolutely: I do not know why you are taking it, but this dose is safe and often the dose I start at when using it with my patients. In general, I am typically worried about too low levels of magnesium in patients rather than too high. Excessive intake of magnesium will result in loose stools. ...Read more

10

10
Is it ok to take Metoprolol XL and Magnesium Glycinate? My EP suggested magnesium but I've read some interactions with the two.

Is it ok to take Metoprolol XL and Magnesium Glycinate? My EP suggested magnesium but I've read some interactions with the two.

Interaction checker: You're smart to ask about interactions. Two of best sources for info are your prescribing doc & your dispensing pharmacist. Of course, you have to tell them everything you're taking, including dietary supplements such as magnesium plus OTC (non-prescription) medications. Interaction checkers are also available online (which show no interaction (http://goo. Gl/jKOf8x) btwn Metoprolol & magnesium). ...Read more

11

11
Is it ok to take magnesium glycinate and Xanax (alprazolam) together?

Is it ok to take magnesium glycinate and Xanax (alprazolam) together?

Ask the Dr/druggist: There's no bad reports but that is not a guarantee that it's a good idea. Ask the Dr who prescribed or your pharmacist to be safest. Do this for any new substance to be sure. ...Read more

12

12
What would doctors recommend magnesium citrate vs magnesium glycinate?

Depends: Both can be used in magnesium diciency. Magnesium Citrate used for bowel irrigation and cause diarrhea. Citric acid will increase stomach acid and assimilation & should be taken with meal. The glycine in magnesium glycinate is an Amino Acid which can help with sleep and feeling calm. Least likely to cause loose stools & should be taken at bedtime. ...Read more

13

13
Can too much magnesium glycinate chelate be absorbed in the body (with high doses) and cause permanent damage? Or do good kidneys filter it all out?

Can too much magnesium glycinate chelate be absorbed in the body (with high doses) and cause permanent damage? Or do good kidneys filter it all out?

Likely filtered out: High dose magnesium can cause muscle weakness / fatigue / lethargy, but with good hydration, the kidneys will filter and excrete the excess over time. Use all medications / treatments according to dr's recommendations. Call poison center for specific advice and recommendations if concerned. ...Read more

14

14
Will magnesium glycinate 600 mg help with migraine and cluster headaches?

Unlikely, unless: You possess low levels of magnesium in your body, but worth a try anyway, if you do not have digestion side effects. Maybe, more success can be found with botox, acupuncture, riboflavin, co-q10, butterbur, or feverfew. ...Read more

15

15
How much magnesium glycinate should I take with 1000mg of calcium citrate a day (for osteoporosis)?

How much magnesium glycinate should I take with 1000mg of calcium citrate a day (for osteoporosis)?

Generally none: Check w/your doctor. Magnesium can interfere with the absorption of calcium if you take them together. You don't need to replace magnesium unless you're deficient. ...Read more

16

16
Can I take metoprolol tartrate and magnesium glycinate or will it lower my bp too much?

Can I take metoprolol tartrate and magnesium glycinate or will it lower my bp too much?

BP: Assuming you are getting metoprolol for hypertension.Its an effective agent ;individual response can only be assessed by observation over time;No specific advice re Mg supplements ...Read more

17

17
I am trying magnesium glycinate for anxiety. Should I be taking it with other supplements or vitamins?

I am trying magnesium glycinate for anxiety. Should I be taking it with other supplements or vitamins?

Vitamins are suplmts: If you are anxious you might want to try something different. There are no studies that show vitamins help control anxiety. Usually, they are used for general health. Try to exercise, meditate or do some yoga. ...Read more

18

18
I have read that Magnesium Bisglycinate can cross the Blood Brain Barrier, I wanted to know if Magnesium Glycinate can also do this?

I have read that Magnesium Bisglycinate can cross the Blood Brain Barrier, I wanted to know if Magnesium Glycinate can also do this?

Yes: Realize that many supplement that report magnesium glycinate are actually bisglycinate. But is does cross the blood brain barrier. ...Read more

19

19
Why is Magnesium oxide always recommended by doctors while it has the lowest absorption rate of all types of Magnesium? Why not chelated Glycinate?

Magnesium: Magnesium glycinate is a chelated form that tends to provide the highest levels of absorption and bioavailability and is typically considered ideal for deficiency. Magnesium oxide is a non-chelated type of magnesium and is less well absorbed. Why magnesium oxide is often prescribed likely has to do with its lower price and stool softening properties. ...Read more

20

20
Are there long term side effects of taking too much magnesium glycinate for a week (2000mg)? Ie. Joint/cartilage weakness/deterioration?

Are there long term side effects of taking too much magnesium glycinate for a week (2000mg)? Ie. Joint/cartilage weakness/deterioration?

Probably not good: 2000mg sounds like 5-6 times the recommended daily intake of magnesium (which includes mg from one's diet and whatever supplements she takes). Not sure anybody knows what happens to a previously normal person's joints and cartilage if she takes large daily doses for a long time. ...Read more

21

21
What's the difference from magnesium elemental from magnesium Glycinate/lysinate chelated, sodium bicarbonate, and magnesium oxide?

Diff. Absorption and: Magnesium always occurs as a salt in combination with other things such as chloride, oxide, glycine, citrate, taurine etc.
Some forms are poorly absorbed; for example magnesium oxide is only 4% absorbed, so it does not raise magnesium much but is a good laxative. The best-absorbed are glycinate and taurate and those amino have benefits. See
https://www. Organicnewsroom. Com/magnesium-supplements/ ...Read more

22

22
Is one particular form of magnesium better for heart palpitations? I like Glycinate because it doesn't have a laxative effect. Is this good for palps?

Is one particular form of magnesium better for heart palpitations? I like Glycinate because it doesn't have a laxative effect. Is this good for palps?

Magnesium taurate or: My favorite form of mag. By far is magnesium taurate. Glycinate is a good form too; both are well-absorbed but the taurine in magnesium taurate is good for heart health- see https://tinyurl. Com/hpdlzgl
It's hard to find but there's a good form from Cardiovasculat Research Ltd.
Magnesium orotate, sold as Cardo-Mag, is another good choice.
All will be effective if the cause is low magnesium! ...Read more

23

23
How much magnesium glycinate should I take against 600mg of elemental calcium (carbonate) and 400iu vitamin D3 for osteoporosis?

How much magnesium glycinate should I take against 600mg of elemental calcium (carbonate) and 400iu vitamin D3 for osteoporosis?

About 400- 600 mg: There is no consensus. Some experts advise a 2:1 ratio of cal. To mag others advise a 1:2 ratio. I feel a 1:1 ratio is reasonable. Calcium carbonate is relatively poorly absorbed; citrate is much better. Mag glycinate is well-absorbed. Most adults need 5000 iu of d in fall ; winter for optimal levels. I advise adding vit k to your regime-see http://bit. Ly/1a48ofs ; http://bit. Ly/18qtb7y. ...Read more

24

24
Currently take metformin 2, 000mg daily. Can I take ubiquitous CoQ10, alpha lipoic acid, GTF chromium & glycinate magnesium supplements with metformin?

Currently take metformin 2, 000mg daily. Can I take ubiquitous CoQ10, alpha lipoic acid, GTF chromium & glycinate magnesium supplements with metformin?

Supplements: 27F of unknown medical Hx other than metformin. Wants to know if can take several supplements. ANS. If u need to waste money on unproven supplements that may contain dangerous additives (the are no standards for supplements) then you might consider it. I never recommend them. I would focus on diet & exercise so you don't meet to take metformin either. Get your BMI < 25 & you likely won't need it. ...Read more

25

25
Any interactions? :ashwagandha, magnesium l threonate, taurate, glycinate, fish oil, cdp choline, acetyl l carnitine, alpha lipoic acid, vitamin d, prilosec

Any interactions? :ashwagandha, magnesium l threonate, taurate, glycinate, fish oil, cdp choline, acetyl l carnitine, alpha lipoic acid, vitamin d, prilosec

Why Supplements?: Since you're 17 years old, I am concerned that you are spending time and money wasting it on the supplements that you listed. While some of the substances are present in a healthy diet, there is actually no reason you should be taking them in the form of a supplement. You should be getting all the vitamin D you need in a healthy diet, and the other things, except Prilosec, are unproven. ...Read more

26

26
Hi is is ok if I use dymatize elite recoup contains bcaas, L-glutamine and citrulline malate http://www. Dolphinfitness. Co.Uk/en/dymatize-elite-recoup?

Hi is is ok if I use dymatize elite recoup contains bcaas, L-glutamine and citrulline malate http://www. Dolphinfitness. Co.Uk/en/dymatize-elite-recoup?

Protein drink: It looks like you're on some asthma inhalers, but I don't know what your medical conditions might be. I see nothing in this protein drink which would conflict with use of inhalers http://tinyurl. Com/lspp8gt -- but you need to check with your own physician who knows you better than online physicians like us on healthtap. The product ingredients as listed should be safe for most healthy people. ...Read more

27

27
Can I take citrulline malate, beta alliane, creatine and l-argine together to gain muscle, size and strength?

Can I take citrulline malate, beta alliane, creatine and l-argine together to gain muscle, size and strength?

Taken together: You can take them together but that is not what will cause you to gain muscle size & strength. You gain size and strength from the actual exercises performed and the amount of protein you consume to repair the overtaxed muscle after the exercise. Consult your family physican or a sports medicine doc for proper guidance. ...Read more

28

28
Is the citrulline malate fine for 16 years old person? Want to take scivation xtend supplement and contain citrulline malate can it stunt the growth?

Is the citrulline malate fine for 16 years old person? Want to take scivation xtend supplement and contain citrulline malate can it stunt the growth?

No proof growth stun: No proof it will stunt growth, has no fda warning, citrulline is one the few hundreds of body building 'supplements' that has scientific validity, this exogenous source in L-arginine cycle that helps muscle built up, reduce the fatigue, also, not for him, this path way with nitrous oxide acts as vascular dilator on the endothelium will help erectile dysfunction, . ...Read more

29

29
I am experiencing erectile dysfunction. Can I take Citrulline Malate with my Adderall? Thank you.

I am experiencing erectile dysfunction. Can I take Citrulline Malate with my Adderall? Thank you.

Lack of Data: There are no reported drug interactions when taking Citrulline Malate together with Adderall. However, because Citrulline Malate is a nutritional supplement and not a prescription medication, there it isn’t as well studied, and just because information is lacking doesn’t mean interactions are not possible. ...Read more

30

30
Is supplements which contain citrulline malate fine for 16 years old person or it will has any side effects on height or kidneys or livers or bones?

Is supplements which contain citrulline malate fine for 16 years old person or it will has any side effects on height or kidneys or livers or bones?

Nobody really knows: Such supplements are not studied enough by researchers because these supplements are not fda-approved drugs for treating particular disorders. Nobody knows for sure what may happen if a teen takes performance-enhancing supplements. So, it is best for all young athletes to train and build their bodies the natural way, with healthy foods, avoiding sports supplements or body-building supplements. ...Read more

31

31
Is it okay to take Citrulline malate (100%) as a pre workout whilst on oral contraceptive pills?

Is it okay to take Citrulline malate (100%) as a pre workout whilst on oral contraceptive pills?

Don't bother.: Save your money. There is no decent, independent study of sufficient size and quality to say that it will do anything for you, good or bad. Any study has been on only a handful of subjects. (less than 50 for the effect tested for). You make plenty of your own citrulline already. See http://www. Lifescript. Com/health/centers/alzheimers/alternative_treatments/citrulline. Aspx ...Read more

32

32
Best form of magnesium?

Why need it?: If for supplementing a low mag level, use magoxide. If for treating constipation, mag citrate is best. Be cautious of self prescribed mag since it may be a problem for some people like those with weak kidneys or on meds that can retain magnesium like spironolactone. ...Read more

33

33
What is the medicinal use of magnesium?

What is the medicinal use of magnesium?

Several ways: A low magnesium can cause arrythmias such as svt/vt etc. In pts taking diueretics magnesuim and potassium can be depleted. You need to replace these to avoid tripping off an irregular heart rythm. ...Read more

35

35
What amount magnesium am I actually getting from this?

Magnesium: You don't say what you are asking about the magnesium content for. Please re-submit and I'll be happy to helps you. ...Read more

36

36
What foods should I consume to get my magnesium and phoshate up?

Organic vegetables: Organic vegetables, fruit, and nuts are good.
http://drfairchild. Blogspot. Com/2012/12/magnesium-benefits. Html. ...Read more

38

38
Milk o magnesium side effeects?

Side effects: In the setting of kidney disease, milk of magnesia (magnesium hydroxide) can lead to dangerously elevated magnesium levels. If you have no kidney disease, the most common side effects are diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting. ...Read more

39

39
How much magnesium is in citrate?

Wrong question: Magnesium citrate is a magnesium preparation in salt form (in a 1:1 ratio of magnesium atom per citrate molecules). Packager: Cardinal Health 1.745 g of Magnesium citrate in 29.6 mL or Magnesium citrate 1.745 g per fl oz. Https://dailymed. Nlm. Nih. Gov/dailymed/drugInfo. Cfm? Setid=1df72d29-612d-4767-b8fc-ba2efc1665d1 ...Read more

40

40
Is magnesium good for trapped nerve?

Is magnesium good for trapped nerve?

Depends: Magnesium is highly beneficial, and most people are deficient.
However, magnesium by itself will not fix a trapped nerve. Surgery may be needed.
http://drfairchild. Blogspot. Com/2012/12/magnesium. Html. ...Read more