Top
40
Doctor insights on: Hannah Poling Autism And Vaccines Court Case

Share
1

1
What is your understanding of legitimate research about thimerosal (mercury) in influenza vaccines?

What is your understanding of legitimate research about thimerosal (mercury) in influenza vaccines?

Benign product: Interest in thimersol increased after the fda randomly assigned a risk level (little evidence) & mfgs decided to remove it from most vaccines out of caution. It remains in the multidose influenza vaccine vials due to its proven safety & effectiveness in protecting the vaccine.Suggestions of a link to autism have been disproven. Today you get more mercury/yr from your diet than was ever in the vacc. ...Read more

Dr. Johanna Fricke
531 doctors shared insights

Autism Spectrum Disorder (Definition)

ASD are a spectrum of disorders of varying degrees that are characterized by difficulties in social interaction, verbal and nonverbal communication and repetitive behaviors. Autism statistics from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) identify around 1 in 68 American children as ...Read more


2

2
Where do researchers get subjects for child abuse research? Who consents? What child agrees to be abused while research is conducted?

Where do researchers get subjects for child abuse research? Who consents? What child agrees to be abused while research is conducted?

Misconceptions: Research often falls into 2 separate types.In forward looking studies, you study a control group and one under the study conditions. In rear looking research, you compare a control group to those who underwent the conditions in the past. Most child abuse research is done as rear looking (retrospective) studies. Your confusion is valid, no review board would allow a kid to be put in such conditions. ...Read more

See 3 more doctor answers
3

3
Is it mental abuse for daycare workers to argue with parents in front of children?

Is it mental abuse for daycare workers to argue with parents in front of children?

Certainly no help: Whether or not this constitutes mental abuse is probably a matter of degree and definition. The obvious question is why this conversation was begun in the presence of the children, and how it degenerated into an argument. Neither party appears to be acting like thoughtful adults, and the children will certainly not benefit from observing and then potentially copying this behavior. ...Read more

4

4
Person i knew who was prodigy in visual arts committed suicide at 23. Is there some link btw the arts and suicide?

Person i knew who was prodigy in visual arts committed suicide at 23. Is there some link btw the arts and suicide?

Possibly: Though there is no specific correlation, there may be a higher incidence of "mental illness" among artists and many individuals with mental illness are very artistic. Many very well known artists have suffered from schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. One example is vangough. The stigma of mental illness leads to reluctance to seek help and leads to vulnerability to suicide. ...Read more

6

6
Are the school fire safety program drills traumatic to kids?

Are the school fire safety program drills traumatic to kids?

No: It actually helps them to know what to do so they do not panic if sa fire would occur. ...Read more

See 2 more doctor answers
7

7
How has the polio vaccine provided new hope for long-time workers?

How has the polio vaccine provided new hope for long-time workers?

What is theQuestion?: New hope is there that one day soon there will be no Polo anywhere in the world as it has been wiped out in all the countries except Afganistan,Pakistan and Nigeria. What it has to do with long time workers I do not understand what is this and I can not answer ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
8

8
Do people really believe MMR vaccines cause autism in children?

Do people really believe MMR vaccines cause autism in children?

False associations : The vaccine haters have tried to link shots to crib death, cerebral palsy & now autism over the past 30 yrs. Each time the science & biology have proven them wrong. The british doc who claimed MMR triggered cases lost his license when his fraudulent research was exposed. Autism is emerging as a gene linked defect & future research may point to its origin, but it has found no link to vaccines. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
9

9
The kern country veterans service department gave it to me that letter says we r trying a claim of fermin Rodriguez for dependent indemnity compensation. In order to win this claim the death certificate must be amended to show in block 112 ischemic heart

The kern country veterans service department gave it to me that letter says we r trying a claim of fermin Rodriguez for dependent indemnity compensation. In order to win this claim the death certificate must be amended to show in block 112 ischemic heart

Inappropriate: It sounds as if you are asking someone on healthtap to amend a death certificate for you. That won't happen. The patient's own physician or the one filling out the death certificate in the first place would be the appropriate places to seek this. ...Read more

10

10
How MMR vaccination is related to autism?

How MMR vaccination is related to autism?

No connection: Mmr vaccination has been conclusively shown by multiple studies to have no connection with autism. The intiial studies suggesting this have been debunked and shown to be fraudulent. ...Read more

See 10 more doctor answers
11

11
Overheard resident say "flk" and attending say my child needs to see pediatric geneticist. What was that about?

Medical slang: Flk stands for “funny-looking kid, ” and was a general term for infants affected with various malformation syndromes, particularly those involving multiple facial abnormalities. Considered demeaning and insensitive, it is no longer in use. ...Read more

See 2 more doctor answers
Dr. Joseph Jeu Dr. Jeu
2 doctors agreed:
12

12
Abused by teacher in '80s. School never believed me/my parents. Abuser now sunday school teacher at church. How can I be credible in warning church?

Dr. Joseph Jeu Dr. Jeu
2 doctors agreed:
Abused by teacher in '80s. School never believed me/my parents. Abuser now sunday school teacher at church. How can I be credible in warning church?

Police: Child abuse is very serious. They need to be stopped from harming other children. You need to report the child abuse to the police as soon as possible. It will require great courage on your part, but i know you can do it. Be brave, protect others. ...Read more

13

13
What is the legal accountability of the ppo primary care? We don't need someone with preceived authority but with no real accountability to me. Accountability/liability and authority go hand in hand

What is the legal accountability of the ppo primary care? We don't need someone with preceived authority but with no real accountability to me.  Accountability/liability and authority go hand in hand

Please see below: Noted several of your posts. Sounds like u r pretty frustrated & angry. Perhaps at a provider &/or insurer. I'm not sure anything we can say here will help much. If ur issue is w a provider, i'd encourage u to try to work w them to clarify a poss misunderstanding. Or get a 2nd opinion. Dealing w an insurer can be more difficult & may require persistence. But try working w their cust svc. Take care. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
14

14
Was Sigmund Freud a doctor? Are his psychoanalytic theories important in the medical community?

Was Sigmund Freud a doctor? Are his psychoanalytic theories important in the medical community?

Freud: Freud was an MD, and started his career as a neurologist, before developing his seminal theories of psychoanalysis. I would say nor only some of Freud's theories, but the psychoanalytic theories that have developed since then to the present time have importance to the medical community, most notable in psychiatry and psychology. ...Read more

15

15
Is autism connected to MMR vaccine?

Is autism connected to MMR vaccine?

NOOOOOOOO !!!!!!!: After millions of dollars of research, ample proof that wakefield is a fraud, and years of misinformation, there is zero evidence of this connection. And all proof that is not. ...Read more

See 6 more doctor answers
16

16
My 16 yo son received an invitation to national academy of future physicians conference in dc. Anyone know if this is legit?

My 16 yo son received an invitation to national academy of future physicians conference in dc. Anyone know if this is legit?

I am not sure: Googling the national academy of future physicians, yielded a lot of self promotion articles. I would suggest looking at health careers programs that are connected to established universities and colleges. The best places to check would be the "sponsoring agencies" listed on their website. Perhaps another healthtap physician will have a more complete answer. ...Read more

See 2 more doctor answers
Dr. James Lin Dr. Lin
1 doctor agreed:
17

17
I just received an invitation to attend the Congress of future Medical Leaders in Boston Massachusetts. Have any doctors on here been to it before?

Dr. James Lin Dr. Lin
1 doctor agreed:

Here are some...: Congratulate you for bringing such inquiry; though unable to offer its answer, I wish one of my colleagues may provide right info for you. But I would still need to remind you of my view as follows: Revealing the truth & facts of life should be the 1st step to improve the future, not political correctness and commercialism,both obscure and cover up the truth leading to more and more calamities... ...Read more

19

19
Is it looked down upon in med school admissions committees to have previously been a nurse?

Is it looked down upon in med school admissions committees to have previously been a nurse?

Nurse to doctor: Perhaps in the past, but these days med schools like a wide variety of backgrounds—biology, music, teaching, pharmacy, sports, etc—as long as the candidate has successfully completed required science & math courses. Having been a nurse gives you an edge in practical, clinical knowledge over your classmates in the first year or two. ...Read more

20

20
Is anyone keeping there child off school because of swine flu?

Is anyone keeping there child off school because of swine flu?

No: The best way to protect your child from any influenza: good handwashing, keep hands away from mouth, eyes, nose, and vaccinate the child and everyone in his environment. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
21

21
Do vaccinations cause autism?

Do vaccinations cause autism?

False associations: The vaccine haters have tried to link shots to crib death, cerebral palsy & now autism over the past 40 yrs. Each time the science & biology have proven them wrong. The british GI doc who claimed MMR triggered cases lost his license when his fraudulent research was exposed. Autism is emerging as a gene linked defect & future research may point to its origin, but it has found no link to vaccines ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
22

22
Can vaccines cause autism?

No: The british doctor who created this entire controversy has admitted the entire thing was a hoax and that he falsified the data. Vaccines are safe and effective and help to save lives and minimize debilities due to overwhelming infections. They do not cause autism. ...Read more

See 2 more doctor answers
23

23
What is the deal with autism and vaccines?

See below: There is absolutely no association between vaccines and autism. There have been multiple studies that have dis-proven any association. And, the original study that suggested an association between MMR and autism has been removed. The data in the study was made up. ...Read more

See 3 more doctor answers
24

24
Which vaccines are thought to cause autism?

Which vaccines are thought to cause autism?

None: Wakefield published some data in 1998 that suggested a link to MMR vaccine.In the years that followed, many promoted this idea.In testimony in washington, dc, the fraudulent nature of his research was exposed.He has since lost his medical license and left britain in shame.Other researchers have refuted his findings, and found it to be a hoax.Many kids have died because parents failed to vaccinate. ...Read more

25

25
Why do people think vaccines lead to autism?

Why do people think vaccines lead to autism?

Unethical: A paper published several years ago linked autism to MMR vaccination. Since then many follow up studies and investigations have disproven it completely. The author of the original study was later found to have altered his results due to having financial gain out of such results. It is a sad case of unethical medical behavior which has caused much confusion. ...Read more

See 4 more doctor answers
26

26
Is there a link between autism and vaccines?

Is there a link between autism and vaccines?

False associations : The vaccine haters have tried to link shots to crib death, cerebral palsy, now autism over the past 30 yrs. Each time science has proven them wrong. The british doc who claimed MMR triggered cases lost his license when his fraudulent research was exposed. Autism is emerging as a gene or chromosome linked defect.Future research may point to its origin, but it has found no link to vaccines. ...Read more

See 3 more doctor answers
27

27
What exactly is the link between vaccines and autism?

Absolutely None: After millions of dollars of research not 1 link between vaccines and autism has been established.Other than the unvaccinated kids get autism as often as those vaccinated and are more likely to be sick with diseases that the vaccines prevent. ...Read more

See 2 more doctor answers
28

28
Which specific vaccines are linked to autism disorder?

Which specific vaccines are linked to autism disorder?

None: No vaccine is linked to autism. The one article that advanced this idea was published in a british medical journal, the lancet, a few years ago. Last year, the author admitted that he had falsified the data. Avoiding proper vaccination on these grounds is not only harmful to your child, but to the population as a whole. ...Read more

See 2 more doctor answers
30

30
Are the vaccines that were associated with autism made in the usa?

There are none: Wakefield & associates in great britain falsified lab data & published an article suggesting a link of vaccines to autism. The research has been debunked, he lost his license but gained big bucks from the lawyers he was working with.The fear generated by the hoax has led many parents to avoid vaccines & in increase in deaths to whooping cough & other vaccine prevented diseases.Sad but true. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
31

31
I heard that vaccines cause autism. I am thinking of foregoing vaccines.

Put This To Bed: Immunizations may be the single safest, most effective heath intervention produced in the last 100 years. They are proven to be 99% effective, safe and haved saved literally millions of children's lives. There is no scientific evidence that any vaccine causes autism and huge amounts of independent research proving that that they do not cause autism. Immunize! ...Read more

See 11 more doctor answers
33

33
Is it really the case that when you get certain vaccines, your future children can get autism?

No: There is no evidence based studies that support this idea. This is a cult idea promoted by the anti-vaccine crowd in the present era.Thirty years ago they pushed the idea it caused cerebral palsy, twenty years ago they pushed the idea it caused crib death. As each issue is eventually proven unrelated they take up a new idea.Sadly, their efforts have resulted in much fear & many preventable deaths. ...Read more

34

34
If studies show vaccines don't cause autism why do celebrities like jenny mccarthy still claim it?

They're confused : Celebrities aren't experts. They have opinions just like anyone else. Their opinions are personal, and unsupported by data or research. Believe competent experts, not hollywood idiots. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
35

35
Honest opinions from whomever that would like to answer: Do vaccines (any) make you sick and/or cause Autism?

No: No clinical evidence that vaccines cause Autism. The benefits of vaccines far outweigh their possible adverse effects. ...Read more

See 2 more doctor answers
36

36
Have researchers discovered some reported cases of children who have not received vaccinations developing autism?

Have researchers discovered some reported cases of children who have not received vaccinations developing autism?

No link connecting: Not only are there cases of children developing autism who have not received vaccines, there is no shred of evidence to support vaccines as causing autism. The article that purported to show this has been retracted. Millions of dollars have been spent looking for this link and not a single link has been found. Don't listen to jenny mccarthy, follow the science. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
37

37
Is it possible there is proof vaccines are connected with autism?

Is it possible there is proof vaccines are connected with autism?

No credible evidence: The vaccine haters have tried to link shots to crib death, cerebral palsy and now autism over the past 30 yrs. Each time the science has proven them wrong. The british doc who claimed MMR triggered cases lost his license when his fraudulent research was exposed. Autism is emerging as a gene linked defect.Future research may point to its origin, but it has found no link to vaccines. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
39

39
Do vaccinations have a big roll in so many children having autism?

Do vaccinations have a big roll in so many children having autism?

False associations : Over more than 30 yrs, the vaccine haters have tried to link shots to crib death, cerebral palsy and now autism. Each time science has proven them wrong. The british doc who claimed MMR triggered autism cases lost his license when his fraudulent research was exposed. Autism is emerging as a gene linked defect, future research may point to its origin, but it has found no link to vaccines. ...Read more

See 1 more doctor answer
Dr. Johanna Fricke
643 doctors shared insights

Autism (Definition)

A neurodevelopmental disorder negatively affecting a person's socialization, communication, and interests. It is usually detected in the first ...Read more